-
A comparison of graphical methods in the case of the murder of Meredith Kercher
Authors:
A. Philip Dawid,
Francesco Dotto,
Maxine Graves,
Jay B. Kadane,
Julia Mortera,
Gail Robertson,
Jim Q. Smith,
Amy L. Wilson
Abstract:
We compare three graphical methods for displaying evidence in a legal case: Wigmore Charts, Bayesian Networks and Chain Event Graphs. We find that these methods are aimed at three distinct audiences, respectively lawyers, forensic scientists and the police. The methods are illustrated using part of the evidence in the case of the murder of Meredith Kercher. More specifically, we focus on represent…
▽ More
We compare three graphical methods for displaying evidence in a legal case: Wigmore Charts, Bayesian Networks and Chain Event Graphs. We find that these methods are aimed at three distinct audiences, respectively lawyers, forensic scientists and the police. The methods are illustrated using part of the evidence in the case of the murder of Meredith Kercher. More specifically, we focus on representing the list of propositions, evidence, testimony and facts given in the first trial against Raffaele Sollecito and Amanda Knox with these graphical methodologies.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Healthcare serial killer or coincidence? Statistical issues in investigation of suspected medical misconduct
Authors:
P. J. Green,
R. D. Gill,
N. Mackenzie,
J. Mortera,
W. C. Thompson
Abstract:
Justice systems are sometimes called upon to evaluate cases in which health-care professionals are suspected of killing their patients illegally. These cases are difficult to evaluate because they involve at least two levels of uncertainty. Commonly in a murder case it is clear that a homicide has occurred, and investigators must resolve uncertainty about who is responsible. In the cases we examin…
▽ More
Justice systems are sometimes called upon to evaluate cases in which health-care professionals are suspected of killing their patients illegally. These cases are difficult to evaluate because they involve at least two levels of uncertainty. Commonly in a murder case it is clear that a homicide has occurred, and investigators must resolve uncertainty about who is responsible. In the cases we examine here there is also uncertainty about whether homicide has occurred. Investigators need to consider whether the deaths that prompted the investigation could plausibly have occurred for reasons other than homicide, in addition to considering whether, if homicide was indeed the cause, the person under suspicion is responsible. In this report, prepared under the auspices of the Royal Statistical Society, we provide advice and guidance on the investigation and evaluation of such cases. Our work was prompted by concerns about the statistical challenges such cases pose for the legal system.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Statistical Analyses in the case of an Italian nurse accused of murdering patients
Authors:
Francesco Dotto,
Richard D. Gill,
Julia Mortera
Abstract:
Suspicions about medical murder sometimes arise due to a surprising or unexpected series of events, such as an apparently unusual number of deaths among patients under the care of a particular nurse. But also a single disturbing event might trigger suspicion about a particular nurse, and this might then lead to investigation of events which happened when she was thought to be present. In either ca…
▽ More
Suspicions about medical murder sometimes arise due to a surprising or unexpected series of events, such as an apparently unusual number of deaths among patients under the care of a particular nurse. But also a single disturbing event might trigger suspicion about a particular nurse, and this might then lead to investigation of events which happened when she was thought to be present. In either case, there is a statistical challenge of distinguishing event clusters that arise from criminal acts from those that arise coincidentally from other causes. We show that an apparently striking association between a nurse's presence and a high rate of deaths in a hospital ward can easily be completely spurious. In short: in a medium-care hospital ward where many patients are suffering terminal illnesses, and deaths are frequent, most deaths occur in the morning. Most nurses are on duty in the morning, too. There are less deaths in the afternoon, and even less at night; correspondingly, less nurses are on duty in the afternoon, even less during the night. Consequently, a full time nurse works the most hours when the most deaths occur. The death rate is higher when she is present than when she is absent.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2022; v1 submitted 4 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Casework applications of probabilistic genotyping methods for DNA mixtures that allow relationships between contributors
Authors:
Peter J. Green,
Julia Mortera,
Lourdes Prieto
Abstract:
In both criminal cases and civil cases there is an increasing demand for the analysis of DNA mixtures involving relationships. The goal might be, for example, to identify the contributors to a DNA mixture where the donors may be related, or to infer the relationship between individuals based on a DNA mixture. This paper applies a recent approach to modelling and computation for DNA mixtures involv…
▽ More
In both criminal cases and civil cases there is an increasing demand for the analysis of DNA mixtures involving relationships. The goal might be, for example, to identify the contributors to a DNA mixture where the donors may be related, or to infer the relationship between individuals based on a DNA mixture. This paper applies a recent approach to modelling and computation for DNA mixtures involving contributors with arbitrarily complex relationships to two real cases from the Spanish Forensic Police.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2021; v1 submitted 24 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Inference about complex relationships using peak height data from DNA mixtures
Authors:
Peter J. Green,
Julia Mortera
Abstract:
In both criminal cases and civil cases there is an increasing demand for the analysis of DNA mixtures involving relationships. The goal might be, for example, to identify the contributors to a DNA mixture where the donors may be related, or to infer the relationship between individuals based on a mixture.
This paper introduces an approach to modelling and computation for DNA mixtures involving c…
▽ More
In both criminal cases and civil cases there is an increasing demand for the analysis of DNA mixtures involving relationships. The goal might be, for example, to identify the contributors to a DNA mixture where the donors may be related, or to infer the relationship between individuals based on a mixture.
This paper introduces an approach to modelling and computation for DNA mixtures involving contributors with arbitrarily complex relationships. It builds on an extension of Jacquard's condensed coefficients of identity, to specify and compute with joint relationships, not only pairwise ones, including the possibility of inbreeding. The methodology developed is applied to two casework examples involving a missing person, and simulation studies of performance, in which the ability of the methodology to recover complex relationship information from synthetic data with known `true' family structure is examined.
The methods used to analyse the examples are implemented in the new KinMix R package, that extends the DNAmixtures package to allow for modelling DNA mixtures with related contributors. KinMix inherits from DNAmixtures the capacity to deal with mixtures with many contributors, in a time- and space-efficient way.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2021; v1 submitted 19 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Analysis of a DNA mixture case involving Romani reference populations
Authors:
Francesco Dotto,
Julia Mortera,
Laura Baldasarri,
Vincenzo Pascali
Abstract:
Here we present an Italian criminal case that shows how statistical methods can be used to extract information from a series of mixed DNA profiles. The case involves several different individuals and a set of different DNA traces. The case possibly involves persons of interest of a small, inbred population of Romani origin. First, a brief description of the case is provided. Secondly, we introduce…
▽ More
Here we present an Italian criminal case that shows how statistical methods can be used to extract information from a series of mixed DNA profiles. The case involves several different individuals and a set of different DNA traces. The case possibly involves persons of interest of a small, inbred population of Romani origin. First, a brief description of the case is provided. Secondly, we introduce some heuristic tools that can be used to evaluate the data and briefly outline the statistical model used for analysing DNA mixtures. Finally, we illustrate some of the findings on the case and discuss further directions of research. The results show how the use of different population database allele frequencies for analysing the DNA mixtures can lead to very different results, some seemingly inculpatory and some seemingly exculpatory. We also illustrate the results obtained from combining the evidence from different samples.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
A Note on Prediction Markets
Authors:
A. Philip Dawid,
Julia Mortera
Abstract:
In a prediction market, individuals can sequentially place bets on the outcome of a future event. This leaves a trail of personal probabilities for the event, each being conditional on the current individual's private background knowledge and on the previously announced probabilities of other individuals, which give partial information about their private knowledge. By means of theory and examples…
▽ More
In a prediction market, individuals can sequentially place bets on the outcome of a future event. This leaves a trail of personal probabilities for the event, each being conditional on the current individual's private background knowledge and on the previously announced probabilities of other individuals, which give partial information about their private knowledge. By means of theory and examples, we revisit some results in this area. In particular, we consider the case of two individuals, who start with the same overall probability distribution but different private information, and then take turns in updating their probabilities. We note convergence of the announced probabilities to a limiting value, which may or may not be the same as that based on pooling their private information.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Paternity testing and other inference about relationships from DNA mixtures
Authors:
Peter J. Green,
Julia Mortera
Abstract:
We present methods for inference about relationships between contributors to a DNA mixture and other individuals of known genotype: a basic example would be testing whether a contributor to a mixture is the father of a child of known genotype. The evidence for such a relationship is evaluated as the likelihood ratio for the specified relationship versus the alternative that there is no such relati…
▽ More
We present methods for inference about relationships between contributors to a DNA mixture and other individuals of known genotype: a basic example would be testing whether a contributor to a mixture is the father of a child of known genotype. The evidence for such a relationship is evaluated as the likelihood ratio for the specified relationship versus the alternative that there is no such relationship. We analyse real casework examples from a criminal case and a disputed paternity case; in both examples part of the evidence was from a DNA mixture. DNA samples are of varying quality and therefore present challenging problems in interpretation. Our methods are based on a recent statistical model for DNA mixtures, in which a Bayesian network (BN) is used as a computational device; the present work builds on that approach, but makes more explicit use of the BN in the modelling. The R code for the analyses presented is freely available as supplementary material.
We show how additional information of specific genotypes relevant to the relationship under analysis greatly strengthens the resulting inference. We find that taking full account of the uncertainty inherent in a DNA mixture can yield likelihood ratios very close to what one would obtain if we had a single source DNA profile. Furthermore, the methods can be readily extended to analyse different scenarios as our methods are not limited to the particular genotyping kits used in the examples, to the allele frequency databases used, to the numbers of contributors assumed, to the number of traces analysed simultaneously, nor to the specific hypotheses tested.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2017; v1 submitted 30 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Analysis of Forensic DNA Mixtures with Artefacts
Authors:
R. G. Cowell,
T. Graversen,
S. Lauritzen,
J. Mortera
Abstract:
DNA is now routinely used in criminal investigations and court cases, although DNA samples taken at crime scenes are of varying quality and therefore present challenging problems for their interpretation. We present a statistical model for the quantitative peak information obtained from an electropherogram (EPG) of a forensic DNA sample and illustrate its potential use for the analysis of criminal…
▽ More
DNA is now routinely used in criminal investigations and court cases, although DNA samples taken at crime scenes are of varying quality and therefore present challenging problems for their interpretation. We present a statistical model for the quantitative peak information obtained from an electropherogram (EPG) of a forensic DNA sample and illustrate its potential use for the analysis of criminal cases. In contrast to most previously used methods, we directly model the peak height information and incorporates important artefacts associated with the production of the EPG. Our model has a number of unknown parameters, and we show that these can be estimated by the method of maximum likelihood in the presence of multiple unknown contributors, and their approximate standard errors calculated; the computations exploit a Bayesian network representation of the model. A case example from a UK trial, as reported in the literature, is used to illustrate the efficacy and use of the model, both in finding likelihood ratios to quantify the strength of evidence, and in the deconvolution of mixtures for the purpose of finding likely profiles of one or more unknown contributors to a DNA sample. Our model is readily extended to simultaneous analysis of more than one mixture as illustrated in a case example. We show that combination of evidence from several samples may give an evidential strength close to that of a single source trace and thus modelling of peak height information provides for a potentially very efficient mixture analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2013; v1 submitted 18 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
Object-oriented Bayesian networks for a decision support system for antitrust enforcement
Authors:
Julia Mortera,
Paola Vicard,
Cecilia Vergari
Abstract:
We study an economic decision problem where the actors are two firms and the Antitrust Authority whose main task is to monitor and prevent firms' potential anti-competitive behaviour and its effect on the market. The Antitrust Authority's decision process is modelled using a Bayesian network where both the relational structure and the parameters of the model are estimated from a data set provided…
▽ More
We study an economic decision problem where the actors are two firms and the Antitrust Authority whose main task is to monitor and prevent firms' potential anti-competitive behaviour and its effect on the market. The Antitrust Authority's decision process is modelled using a Bayesian network where both the relational structure and the parameters of the model are estimated from a data set provided by the Authority itself. A number of economic variables that influence this decision process are also included in the model. We analyse how monitoring by the Antitrust Authority affects firms' strategies about cooperation. Firms' strategies are modelled as a repeated prisoner's dilemma using object-oriented Bayesian networks. We show how the integration of firms' decision process and external market information can be modelled in this way. Various decision scenarios and strategies are illustrated.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2013; v1 submitted 8 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
MAIES: A Tool for DNA Mixture Analysis
Authors:
Robert G. Cowell,
Steffen L. Lauritzen,
Julia Mortera
Abstract:
We describe an expert system, MAIES, developed for analysing forensic identification problems involving DNA mixture traces using quantitative peak area information. Peak area information is represented by conditional Gaussian distributions, and inference based on exact junction tree propagation ascertains whether individuals, whose profiles have been measured, have contributed to the mixture. The…
▽ More
We describe an expert system, MAIES, developed for analysing forensic identification problems involving DNA mixture traces using quantitative peak area information. Peak area information is represented by conditional Gaussian distributions, and inference based on exact junction tree propagation ascertains whether individuals, whose profiles have been measured, have contributed to the mixture. The system can also be used to predict DNA profiles of unknown contributors by separating the mixture into its individual components. The use of the system is illustrated with an application to a real world example. The system implements a novel MAP (maximum a posteriori) search algorithm that is described in an appendix.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Sensitivity of inferences in forensic genetics to assumptions about founding genes
Authors:
Peter J. Green,
Julia Mortera
Abstract:
Many forensic genetics problems can be handled using structured systems of discrete variables, for which Bayesian networks offer an appealing practical modeling framework, and allow inferences to be computed by probability propagation methods. However, when standard assumptions are violated--for example, when allele frequencies are unknown, there is identity by descent or the population is heter…
▽ More
Many forensic genetics problems can be handled using structured systems of discrete variables, for which Bayesian networks offer an appealing practical modeling framework, and allow inferences to be computed by probability propagation methods. However, when standard assumptions are violated--for example, when allele frequencies are unknown, there is identity by descent or the population is heterogeneous--dependence is generated among founding genes, that makes exact calculation of conditional probabilities by propagation methods less straightforward. Here we illustrate different methodologies for assessing sensitivity to assumptions about founders in forensic genetics problems. These include constrained steepest descent, linear fractional programming and representing dependence by structure. We illustrate these methods on several forensic genetics examples involving criminal identification, simple and complex disputed paternity and DNA mixtures.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
-
Discussion of: Statistical analysis of an archeological find
Authors:
J. Mortera,
P. Vicard
Abstract:
Discussion of ``Statistical analysis of an archeological find'' by Andrey Feuerverger [arXiv:0804.0079]
Discussion of ``Statistical analysis of an archeological find'' by Andrey Feuerverger [arXiv:0804.0079]
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2008;
originally announced April 2008.