-
Report of the Topical Group on Physics Beyond the Standard Model at Energy Frontier for Snowmass 2021
Authors:
Tulika Bose,
Antonio Boveia,
Caterina Doglioni,
Simone Pagan Griso,
James Hirschauer,
Elliot Lipeles,
Zhen Liu,
Nausheen R. Shah,
Lian-Tao Wang,
Kaustubh Agashe,
Juliette Alimena,
Sebastian Baum,
Mohamed Berkat,
Kevin Black,
Gwen Gardner,
Tony Gherghetta,
Josh Greaves,
Maxx Haehn,
Phil C. Harris,
Robert Harris,
Julie Hogan,
Suneth Jayawardana,
Abraham Kahn,
Jan Kalinowski,
Simon Knapen
, et al. (297 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This is the Snowmass2021 Energy Frontier (EF) Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) report. It combines the EF topical group reports of EF08 (Model-specific explorations), EF09 (More general explorations), and EF10 (Dark Matter at Colliders). The report includes a general introduction to BSM motivations and the comparative prospects for proposed future experiments for a broad range of potential BSM mode…
▽ More
This is the Snowmass2021 Energy Frontier (EF) Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) report. It combines the EF topical group reports of EF08 (Model-specific explorations), EF09 (More general explorations), and EF10 (Dark Matter at Colliders). The report includes a general introduction to BSM motivations and the comparative prospects for proposed future experiments for a broad range of potential BSM models and signatures, including compositeness, SUSY, leptoquarks, more general new bosons and fermions, long-lived particles, dark matter, charged-lepton flavor violation, and anomaly detection.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2022; v1 submitted 26 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Approaching Petavolts per meter plasmonics using structured semiconductors
Authors:
Aakash A. Sahai,
M. Golkowski,
T. Katsouleas,
G. Andonian,
G. White,
C. Joshi,
P. Taborek,
V. Harid,
J. Stohr
Abstract:
A new class of strongly excited plasmonic modes that open access to unprecedented Petavolts per meter electromagnetic fields promise wide-ranging, transformative impact. These modes are constituted by large amplitude oscillations of the ultradense, delocalized free electron Fermi gas which is inherent in conductive media. Here structured semiconductors with appropriate concentration of n-type dopa…
▽ More
A new class of strongly excited plasmonic modes that open access to unprecedented Petavolts per meter electromagnetic fields promise wide-ranging, transformative impact. These modes are constituted by large amplitude oscillations of the ultradense, delocalized free electron Fermi gas which is inherent in conductive media. Here structured semiconductors with appropriate concentration of n-type dopant are introduced to tune the properties of the Fermi gas for matched excitation of an electrostatic, surface "crunch-in" plasmon using readily available electron beams of ten micron overall dimensions and hundreds of picoCoulomb charge launched inside a tube. Strong excitation made possible by matching results in relativistic oscillations of the Fermi electron gas and uncovers unique phenomena. Relativistically induced ballistic electron transport comes about due to relativistic multifold increase in the mean free path. Acquired ballistic transport also leads to unconventional heat deposition beyond the Ohm's law. This explains the absence of observed damage or solid-plasma formation in experiments on interaction of conductive samples with electron bunches shorter than $\rm 10^{-13} seconds$. Furthermore, relativistic momentum leads to copious tunneling of electron gas allowing it to traverse the surface and crunch inside the tube. Relativistic effects along with large, localized variation of Fermi gas density underlying these modes necessitate the kinetic approach coupled with particle-in-cell simulations. Experimental verification of acceleration and focusing of electron beams modeled here using tens of Gigavolts per meter fields excited in semiconductors with $\rm 10^{18}cm^{-3}$ free electron density will pave the way for Petavolts per meter plasmonics.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
PetaVolts per meter Plasmonics: Snowmass21 White Paper
Authors:
Aakash A. Sahai,
Mark Golkowski,
Stephen Gedney,
Thomas Katsouleas,
Gerard Andonian,
Glen White,
Joachim Stohr,
Patric Muggli,
Daniele Filipetto,
Frank Zimmermann,
Toshiki Tajima,
Gerard Mourou,
Javier Resta-Lopez
Abstract:
Plasmonic modes offer the potential to achieve PetaVolts per meter fields, that would transform the current paradigm in collider development in addition to non-collider searches in fundamental physics. PetaVolts per meter plasmonics relies on collective oscillations of the free electron Fermi gas inherent in the conduction band of materials that have a suitable combination of constituent atoms and…
▽ More
Plasmonic modes offer the potential to achieve PetaVolts per meter fields, that would transform the current paradigm in collider development in addition to non-collider searches in fundamental physics. PetaVolts per meter plasmonics relies on collective oscillations of the free electron Fermi gas inherent in the conduction band of materials that have a suitable combination of constituent atoms and ionic lattice structure. As the conduction band free electron density, at equilibrium, can be as high as $\rm 10^{24}cm^{-3}$, electromagnetic fields of the order of $\rm 0.1 \sqrt{\rm n_0(10^{24}cm^{-3})} ~ PVm^{-1}$ can be sustained by plasmonic modes. Engineered materials not only allow highly tunable material properties but quite critically make it possible to overcome disruptive instabilities that dominate the interactions in bulk media. Due to rapid shielding by the free electron Fermi gas, dielectric effects are strongly suppressed. Because the ionic lattice, the corresponding electronic energy bands and the free electron gas are governed by quantum mechanical effects, comparisons with plasmas are merely notional. Based on this framework, it is critical to address various challenges that underlie PetaVolts per meter plasmonics including stable excitation of plasmonic modes while accounting for their effects on the ionic lattice and the electronic energy band structure over femtosecond timescales. We summarize the ongoing theoretical and experimental efforts as well as map out strategies for the future. Extreme plasmonic fields can shape the future by not only bringing tens of TeV to multi-PeV center-of-mass-energies within reach but also by opening novel pathways in non-collider HEP. In view of this promise, we invite the scientific community to help realize the immense potential of PV/m plasmonics and call for significant expansion of the US and international R\&D program.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Snowmass21 Accelerator Modeling Community White Paper
Authors:
S. Biedron,
L. Brouwer,
D. L. Bruhwiler,
N. M. Cook,
A. L. Edelen,
D. Filippetto,
C. -K. Huang,
A. Huebl,
T. Katsouleas,
N. Kuklev,
R. Lehe,
S. Lund,
C. Messe,
W. Mori,
C. -K. Ng,
D. Perez,
P. Piot,
J. Qiang,
R. Roussel,
D. Sagan,
A. Sahai,
A. Scheinker,
M. Thévenet,
F. Tsung,
J. -L. Vay
, et al. (2 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
After a summary of relevant comments and recommendations from various reports over the last ten years, this paper examines the modeling needs in accelerator physics, from the modeling of single beams and individual accelerator elements, to the realization of virtual twins that replicate all the complexity to model a particle accelerator complex as accurately as possible. We then discuss cutting-ed…
▽ More
After a summary of relevant comments and recommendations from various reports over the last ten years, this paper examines the modeling needs in accelerator physics, from the modeling of single beams and individual accelerator elements, to the realization of virtual twins that replicate all the complexity to model a particle accelerator complex as accurately as possible. We then discuss cutting-edge and emerging computing opportunities, such as advanced algorithms, AI/ML and quantum computing, computational needs in hardware, software performance, portability and scalability, and needs for scalable I/O and in-situ analysis. Considerations of reliability, long-term sustainability, user support and training are considered next, before discussing the benefits of ecosystems with integrated workflows based on standardized input and output, and with integrated frameworks and data repositories developed as a community. Last, we highlight how the community can work more collaboratively and efficiently through the development of consortia and centers, and via collaboration with industry.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2022; v1 submitted 15 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Optimal positron-beam excited plasma wakefields in Hollow and Ion-Wake channels
Authors:
Aakash A. Sahai,
T. C. Katsouleas
Abstract:
A positron-beam interacting with the plasma electrons drives radial suck-in, in contrast to an electron-beam driven blow-out in the over-dense regime, $n_b>n_0$. In a homogeneous plasma, the electrons are radially sucked-in from all the different radii. The electrons collapsing from different radii do not simultaneously compress on-axis driving weak fields. A hollow-channel allows electrons from i…
▽ More
A positron-beam interacting with the plasma electrons drives radial suck-in, in contrast to an electron-beam driven blow-out in the over-dense regime, $n_b>n_0$. In a homogeneous plasma, the electrons are radially sucked-in from all the different radii. The electrons collapsing from different radii do not simultaneously compress on-axis driving weak fields. A hollow-channel allows electrons from its channel-radius to collapse simultaneously exciting coherent fields. We analyze the optimal channel radius. Additionally, the low ion density in the hollow allows a larger region with focusing phase which we show is linearly focusing. We have shown the formation of an ion-wake channel behind a blow-out electron bubble-wake. Here we explore positron acceleration in the over-dense regime comparing an optimal hollow-plasma channel to the ion-wake channel. The condition for optimal hollow-channel radius is also compared. We also address the effects of a non-ideal ion-wake channel on positron-beam excited fields.
△ Less
Submitted 25 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Non-linear Ion-wake Excitation by Ultra-relativistic Electron Wakefields
Authors:
Aakash A. Sahai,
Thomas C. Katsouleas
Abstract:
The excitation of a non-linear ion-wake by a train of ultra-relativistic electron bubble wake [1]-[8] is modeled. The ion-wake is shown to be a driven non-linear ion-acoustic wave in the form of a cylindrical ion-soliton [11]-[14]. The phases of the oscillating radial electric fields of the slowly-propagating [21] electron bubble is asymmetric in time and excites time-averaged inertial ion motion…
▽ More
The excitation of a non-linear ion-wake by a train of ultra-relativistic electron bubble wake [1]-[8] is modeled. The ion-wake is shown to be a driven non-linear ion-acoustic wave in the form of a cylindrical ion-soliton [11]-[14]. The phases of the oscillating radial electric fields of the slowly-propagating [21] electron bubble is asymmetric in time and excites time-averaged inertial ion motion radially. The electron compression in the back of the bubble sucks-in the ions and the space-charge within the bubble cavity expels them, driving a cylindrical ion-soliton structure with on-axis and bubble-edge density-spikes [5][6]. Once formed, the channel-edge density-spike is driven radially outwards by the thermal pressure of the wake energy [12]. Its channel-like structure due to the flat-residue left behind by the propagating ion-soliton, is independent of the energy-source driving the bubble [3][4] electron wake. We explore the use of the partially- filled channel formed by the cylindrical ion-soliton for a novel regime of positron acceleration [18]. OSIRIS PIC [25] simulations are used to study the ion-wake soliton structure, its driven propagation and its use for positron acceleration.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2015; v1 submitted 14 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Longitudinal instabilities affecting the moving critical layer laser-plasma ion accelerators
Authors:
Aakash Ajit Sahai,
Thomas C. Katsouleas
Abstract:
In this work we analyze the longitudinal instabilities of propagating acceleration structures that are driven by a relativistically intense laser at the moving plasma critical layer [1]. These instabilities affect the energy-spectra of the accelerated ion-beams in propagating critical layer acceleration schemes [2][3]. Specifically, using analytical theory and PIC simulations we look into three fu…
▽ More
In this work we analyze the longitudinal instabilities of propagating acceleration structures that are driven by a relativistically intense laser at the moving plasma critical layer [1]. These instabilities affect the energy-spectra of the accelerated ion-beams in propagating critical layer acceleration schemes [2][3]. Specifically, using analytical theory and PIC simulations we look into three fundamental physical processes and their interplay that are crucial to the understanding of energy spectral control by making the laser-plasma ion accelerators stable. The interacting processes are (i) Doppler-shifted ponderomotive bunching [1][4] (ii) potential quenching by beam-loading [2] and (iii) two-stream instabilities. These phenomenon have been observed in simulations analyzing these acceleration processes [5][6][7]. From the preliminary models and results we present in this work, we can infer measures by which these instabilities can be controlled [8] for improving the energy-spread of the beams.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Self-injection by trapping of plasma electrons oscillating in rising density gradient at the vacuum-plasma interface
Authors:
Aakash A. Sahai,
Thomas C. Katsouleas,
Patric Muggli
Abstract:
We model the trapping of plasma $e^-$ within the density structures excited by a propagating energy source ($β_{S}\simeq1$) in a rising plasma density gradient. Rising density gradient leads to spatially contiguous coupled up-chirped plasmons ($d{ω^2_{pe}(x)}/{dx}>0$). Therefore phase mixing between plasmons can lead to trapping until the plasmon field is high enough such that $e^-$ trajectories r…
▽ More
We model the trapping of plasma $e^-$ within the density structures excited by a propagating energy source ($β_{S}\simeq1$) in a rising plasma density gradient. Rising density gradient leads to spatially contiguous coupled up-chirped plasmons ($d{ω^2_{pe}(x)}/{dx}>0$). Therefore phase mixing between plasmons can lead to trapping until the plasmon field is high enough such that $e^-$ trajectories returning towards a longer wavelength see a trapping potential. Rising plasma density gradients are ubiquitous for confining the plasma within sources at the vacuum-plasma interfaces. Therefore trapping of plasma-$e^-$ in a rising ramp is important for acceleration diagnostics and to understand the energy dissipation from the excited plasmon train \cite{LTE-2013}. Down-ramp in density \cite{density-transition-2001} has been used for plasma-$e^-$ trapping within the first bucket behind the driver. Here, in rising density gradient the trapping does not occur in the first plasmon bucket but in subsequent plasmon buckets behind the driver. Trapping reduces the Hamiltonian of each bucket where $e^-$ are trapped, so it is a wakefield-decay probe. Preliminary computational results for beam and laser-driven wakefield are shown.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Refraction of $e^-$ beams due to plasma lensing at a plasma-vacuum interface -- applied to beam deflection in a Copper cell with electrical RF-breakdown plasma
Authors:
Aakash A. Sahai,
T. C. Katsouleas
Abstract:
We formulate a possible description of the deflection of a relativistic $e^-$ beam in an inhomogeneous copper plasma, encountered by the beam when propagating through a accelerating cell that has undergone a high electric-field RF-breakdown. It is well known that an inhomogeneous plasma forms and may last for up to a few micro-seconds, until recombination in an accelerating structure where a field…
▽ More
We formulate a possible description of the deflection of a relativistic $e^-$ beam in an inhomogeneous copper plasma, encountered by the beam when propagating through a accelerating cell that has undergone a high electric-field RF-breakdown. It is well known that an inhomogeneous plasma forms and may last for up to a few micro-seconds, until recombination in an accelerating structure where a field-emission triggers melting and ionization of RF-cell wall deformity. We present a preliminary model for the beam deflection due to collective plasma response based upon the beam density, plasma density and interaction length.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Proton acceleration by a relativistic laser frequency-chirp driven plasma snowplow
Authors:
Aakash A. Sahai,
T. C. Katsouleas,
R. A. Bingham,
F. S. Tsung,
A. R. Tableman,
M. Tzoufras,
W. B. Mori
Abstract:
We analyze the use of a relativistic laser pulse with a controlled frequency chirp incident on a rising plasma density gradient to drive an acceleration structure for proton and light-ion acceleration. The Chirp Induced Transparency Acceleration (ChITA) scheme is described with an analytical model of the velocity of the snowplow at critical density on a pre-formed rising plasma density gradient th…
▽ More
We analyze the use of a relativistic laser pulse with a controlled frequency chirp incident on a rising plasma density gradient to drive an acceleration structure for proton and light-ion acceleration. The Chirp Induced Transparency Acceleration (ChITA) scheme is described with an analytical model of the velocity of the snowplow at critical density on a pre-formed rising plasma density gradient that is driven by a positive-chirp in the frequency of a relativistic laser pulse. The velocity of the ChITA-snowplow is shown to depend upon rate of rise of the frequency of the relativistic laser pulse represented by $\frac{ε_0}θ$ where, $ε_0 = \frac{Δω_0}{ω_0}$ and chirping spatial scale-length, $θ$, the normalized magnetic vector potential of the laser pulse $a_0$ and the plasma density gradient scale-length, $α$. We observe using 1-D OSIRIS simulations the formation and forward propagation of ChITA-snowplow, being continuously pushed by the chirping laser at a velocity in accordance with the analytical results. The trace protons reflect off of this propagating snowplow structure and accelerate mono-energetically. The control over ChITA-snowplow velocity allows the tuning of accelerated proton energies.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Long Term Evolution of Plasma Wakefields
Authors:
Aakash A. Sahai,
T. C. Katsouleas,
F. S. Tsung,
W. B. Mori
Abstract:
We study the long-term evolution (LTE) of plasma wakefields over multiple plasma-electron periods and few plasma-ion periods, much less than a recombination time. The evolution and relaxation of such a wakefield-perturbed plasma over these timescales has important implications for the upper limits of repetition-rates in plasma colliders. Intense fields in relativistic lasers (or intense beams) cre…
▽ More
We study the long-term evolution (LTE) of plasma wakefields over multiple plasma-electron periods and few plasma-ion periods, much less than a recombination time. The evolution and relaxation of such a wakefield-perturbed plasma over these timescales has important implications for the upper limits of repetition-rates in plasma colliders. Intense fields in relativistic lasers (or intense beams) create plasma wakefields (modes around ωpe) by transferring energy to the plasma electrons. Charged-particle beams in the right phase may be accelerated with acceleration/focusing gradients of tens of GeV/m. However, wakefields leave behind a plasma not in equilibrium, with a relaxation time of multiple plasma-electron periods. Ion motion over ion timescales, caused by energy transfer from the driven plasma-electrons to the plasma-ions can create interesting plasma states. Eventually during LTE, the dynamics of plasma de-coheres (multiple modes through instability driven mixing), thermalizing into random motion (second law of thermodynamics), dissipating energy away from the wakefields. Wakefield-drivers interacting with such a relativistically hot-plasma lead to plasma wakefields that differ from the wakefields in a cold-plasma.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Relativistically Induced Transparency Acceleration (RITA) of Protons and Light-ions with Ultrashort Laser Interaction with Heavy-ion Plasma Density Gradient
Authors:
Aakash A. Sahai,
F. S. Tsung,
A. R. Tableman,
W. B. Mori,
T. C. Katsouleas
Abstract:
The relativistically induced transparency acceleration (RITA) scheme of proton and ion acceleration using laser-plasma interactions is introduced, modeled, and compared to the existing schemes. Protons are accelerated with femtosecond relativistic pulses to produce quasimonoenergetic bunches with controllable peak energy. The RITA scheme works by a relativistic laser inducing transparency to densi…
▽ More
The relativistically induced transparency acceleration (RITA) scheme of proton and ion acceleration using laser-plasma interactions is introduced, modeled, and compared to the existing schemes. Protons are accelerated with femtosecond relativistic pulses to produce quasimonoenergetic bunches with controllable peak energy. The RITA scheme works by a relativistic laser inducing transparency to densities higher than the cold-electron critical density, while the background heavy ions are stationary. The rising laser pulse creates a traveling acceleration structure at the relativistic critical density by ponderomotively driving a local electron density inflation, creating an electron snowplow and a co-propagating electrostatic potential. The snowplow advances with a velocity determined by the rate of the rise of the laser's intensity envelope and the heavy-ion-plasma density gradient scale length. The rising laser is incrementally rendered transparent to higher densities such that the relativistic-electron plasma frequency is resonant with the laser frequency. In the snowplow frame, trace density protons reflect off the electrostatic potential and get snowplowed, while the heavier background ions are relatively unperturbed. Quasimonoenergetic bunches of velocity equal to twice the snowplow velocity can be obtained and tuned by controlling the snowplow velocity using laser-plasma parameters. An analytical model for the proton energy as a function of laser intensity, rise time, and plasma density gradient is developed and compared to 1D and 2D PIC OSIRIS simulations. We model the acceleration of protons to GeV energies with tens-of-femtoseconds laser pulses of a few petawatts. The scaling of proton energy with laser power compares favorably to other mechanisms for ultrashort pulses.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Beam loading in the nonlinear regime of plasma-based acceleration
Authors:
M. Tzoufras,
W. Lu,
F. S. Tsung,
C. Huang,
W. B. Mori,
T. Katsouleas,
J. Vieira,
R. A. Fonseca,
L. O. Silva
Abstract:
A theory that describes how to load negative charge into a nonlinear, three-dimensional plasma wakefield is presented. In this regime, a laser or an electron beam blows out the plasma electrons and creates a nearly spherical ion channel, which is modified by the presence of the beam load. Analytical solutions for the fields and the shape of the ion channel are derived. It is shown that very high…
▽ More
A theory that describes how to load negative charge into a nonlinear, three-dimensional plasma wakefield is presented. In this regime, a laser or an electron beam blows out the plasma electrons and creates a nearly spherical ion channel, which is modified by the presence of the beam load. Analytical solutions for the fields and the shape of the ion channel are derived. It is shown that very high beam-loading efficiency can be achieved, while the energy spread of the bunch is conserved. The theoretical results are verified with the Particle-In-Cell code OSIRIS.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2008;
originally announced September 2008.
