-
Microstructural and Micromechanical Evolution of Olivine Aggregates During Transient Creep
Authors:
Harison S. Wiesman,
Thomas Breithaupt,
David Wallis,
Lars N. Hansen
Abstract:
To examine the microstructural evolution that occurs during transient creep, we deformed olivine aggregates to different strains that spanned the initial transient deformation. Two sets of samples with different initial grain sizes of 5 $μ$m and 20 $μ$m were deformed in torsion at T = 1523 K, P = 300 MPa, and a constant shear strain rate of 1.5 $\times$ 10$^{-4}$ s$^{-1}$. Both sets of samples exp…
▽ More
To examine the microstructural evolution that occurs during transient creep, we deformed olivine aggregates to different strains that spanned the initial transient deformation. Two sets of samples with different initial grain sizes of 5 $μ$m and 20 $μ$m were deformed in torsion at T = 1523 K, P = 300 MPa, and a constant shear strain rate of 1.5 $\times$ 10$^{-4}$ s$^{-1}$. Both sets of samples experienced strain hardening during deformation. We characterized the microstructures at the end of each experiment using high-angular resolution electron backscatter diffraction (HR-EBSD) and dislocation decoration. In the coarse-grained samples, dislocation density increased from 1.5 $\times$ 10$^{11}$ m$^{-2}$ to 3.6 $\times$ 10$^{12}$ m$^{-2}$ with strain. Although the same final dislocation density was reached in the fine-grained samples, it did not vary significantly at small strains, potentially due to concurrent grain growth during deformation. In both sets of samples, HR-EBSD analysis revealed that intragranular stress heterogeneity increased in magnitude with strain and that elevated stresses are associated with regions of high geometrically necessary dislocation density. Further analysis of the stresses and their probability distributions indicate that the stresses are imparted by long-range elastic interactions among dislocations. These characteristics indicate that dislocation interactions were the primary cause of strain hardening during transient creep. A comparison of the results to predictions from three recent models reveals that the models do not correctly predict the evolution in stress and dislocation density with strain for our experiments due to a lack of previous such data in their calibrations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Granular dilatancy and non-local fluidity of partially molten rock
Authors:
Richard F. Katz,
John F. Rudge,
Lars N. Hansen
Abstract:
Partially molten rock is a densely packed, melt-saturated, granular medium, but it has seldom been considered in these terms. In this manuscript, we extend the continuum theory of partially molten rock to incorporate the physics of granular media. Our formulation includes dilatancy in a viscous constitutive law and introduces a non-local fluidity. We analyse the resulting poro-viscous--granular th…
▽ More
Partially molten rock is a densely packed, melt-saturated, granular medium, but it has seldom been considered in these terms. In this manuscript, we extend the continuum theory of partially molten rock to incorporate the physics of granular media. Our formulation includes dilatancy in a viscous constitutive law and introduces a non-local fluidity. We analyse the resulting poro-viscous--granular theory in terms of two modes of liquid--solid segregation that are observed in published torsion experiments: localisation of liquid into high-porosity sheets and radially inward liquid flow. We show that the newly incorporated granular physics brings the theory into agreement with experiments. We discuss these results in the context of grain-scale physics across the nominal jamming fraction at the high homologous temperatures relevant in geological systems.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2023; v1 submitted 18 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
The role of grain-environment heterogeneity in normal grain growth: a stochastic approach
Authors:
Thomas Breithaupt,
Lars N. Hansen,
Srikanth Toppaladoddi,
Richard F. Katz
Abstract:
The size distribution of grains is a fundamental characteristic of polycrystalline solids. In the absence of deformation, the grain-size distribution is controlled by normal grain growth. The canonical model of normal grain growth, developed by Hillert, predicts a grain-size distribution that bears a systematic discrepancy with observed distributions. To address this, we propose a change to the Hi…
▽ More
The size distribution of grains is a fundamental characteristic of polycrystalline solids. In the absence of deformation, the grain-size distribution is controlled by normal grain growth. The canonical model of normal grain growth, developed by Hillert, predicts a grain-size distribution that bears a systematic discrepancy with observed distributions. To address this, we propose a change to the Hillert model that accounts for the influence of heterogeneity in the local environment of grains. In our model, each grain evolves in response to its own local environment of neighbouring grains, rather than to the global population of grains. The local environment of each grain evolves according to an Ornstein-Uhlenbeck stochastic process. Our results are consistent with accepted grain-growth kinetics. Crucially, our model indicates that the size of relatively large grains evolves as a random walk due to the inherent variability in their local environments. This leads to a broader grain-size distribution than the Hillert model and indicates that heterogeneity has a critical influence on the evolution of microstructure.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Biominerals with Texture Gradients are Functionally Graded Bioceramics Toughened by Stress Delocalization
Authors:
David Wallis,
Joe Harris,
Corinna F. Böhm,
Di Wang,
Pablo Zavattieri,
Patrick Feldner,
Benoit Merle,
Vitaliy Pipich,
Katrin Hurle,
Simon Leupold,
Lars N. Hansen,
Frédéric Marin,
Stephan E. Wolf
Abstract:
Biomineralizing organisms are widely noted and extensively studied due to their ability to generate structures exhibiting exceptional crystallographic control. Primarily, it is the organisms, such as sea-urchins or bivalves, that generate nearly single-crystalline biocrystals that have attracted attention. In contrast, biomineralizing organisms with seemingly disordered polycrystalline bio-armor h…
▽ More
Biomineralizing organisms are widely noted and extensively studied due to their ability to generate structures exhibiting exceptional crystallographic control. Primarily, it is the organisms, such as sea-urchins or bivalves, that generate nearly single-crystalline biocrystals that have attracted attention. In contrast, biomineralizing organisms with seemingly disordered polycrystalline bio-armor have been left relatively unstudied. However, the crystalline ordering in the black-lipped pearl oyster, Pinctada margaritifera, reveals that biominerals with varying crystal textures are an unrecognized class of functionally graded materials. Changing crystal textures inevitably cause a variation in Young modulus due to the orientation-dependent mechanical properties of crystals. The case of Pinctada margaritifera demonstrates that bioceramics with such crystallographical gradients are toughened by stress delocalization and reduced stress intensity factors, outperforming non-graded counterparts. These findings suggest that a multitude of biominerals, which are perceived as poorly ordered because of their polycrystallinity and changing crystal textures, may be considered as graded materials with hitherto unidentified emergent mechanical properties. The underlying design principle is remarkably simple and applicable to a wide range of crystalline material classes and may thus serve as a blueprint for future bioinspired functional materials.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Dislocation interactions in olivine control postseismic creep of the upper mantle
Authors:
David Wallis,
Lars N. Hansen,
Angus J. Wilkinson,
Ricardo A. Lebensohn
Abstract:
Changes in stress applied to mantle rocks, such as those imposed by earthquakes, induce a period of evolution in viscosity and microstructure. This transient creep is often modelled based on stress transfer among slip systems due to grain interactions. However, recent experiments have demonstrated that the intragranular accumulation of stresses among dislocations is the dominant cause of strain ha…
▽ More
Changes in stress applied to mantle rocks, such as those imposed by earthquakes, induce a period of evolution in viscosity and microstructure. This transient creep is often modelled based on stress transfer among slip systems due to grain interactions. However, recent experiments have demonstrated that the intragranular accumulation of stresses among dislocations is the dominant cause of strain hardening in olivine at low temperatures, raising the question of whether the same process contributes to transient creep at higher temperatures. Here, we demonstrate that olivine samples deformed at 25°C or 1150 to 1250°C both contain stress heterogeneities of ~1 GPa that are imparted by dislocations and have correlation lengths of ~1 micrometre. The similar stress distributions formed in both temperature regimes indicate that accumulation of stresses among dislocations also provides a contribution to transient creep at high temperatures. The results motivate a new generation of models that capture these intragranular processes and may refine predictions of evolving mantle viscosity over the earthquake cycle.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Dislocation interactions during low-temperature plasticity of olivine strengthen the lithospheric mantle
Authors:
David Wallis,
Lars. N. Hansen,
Kathryn M. Kumamoto,
Christopher A. Thom,
Oliver Plümper,
Markus Ohl,
William B. Durham,
David L. Goldsby,
David E. J. Armstrong,
Cameron D. Meyers,
Rellie Goddard,
Jessica M. Warren,
Thomas Breithaupt,
Martyn R. Drury,
Angus J. Wilkinson
Abstract:
The strength of the lithosphere is typically modelled based on constitutive equations for steady-state flow. However, models of lithospheric flexure reveal differences in lithospheric strength that are difficult to reconcile based on such flow laws. Recent rheological data from low-temperature deformation experiments on olivine suggest that this discrepancy may be largely explained by strain harde…
▽ More
The strength of the lithosphere is typically modelled based on constitutive equations for steady-state flow. However, models of lithospheric flexure reveal differences in lithospheric strength that are difficult to reconcile based on such flow laws. Recent rheological data from low-temperature deformation experiments on olivine suggest that this discrepancy may be largely explained by strain hardening. Details of the mechanical data, specifically the effects of temperature-independent back stresses stored in the samples, indicate that strain hardening in olivine occurs primarily due to long-range elastic interactions between dislocations. These interpretations provided the basis for a new flow law that incorporates hardening by development of back stress. Here, we test this hypothesis by examining the microstructures of olivine samples deformed plastically at room temperature either in a deformation-DIA apparatus at differential stresses of < 4.3 GPa or in a nanoindenter at applied contact stresses of > 10.2 GPa. High-angular resolution electron backscatter diffraction maps reveal the presence of geometrically necessary dislocations with densities commonly above 10$^{14}$ m$^{-2}$ and intragranular heterogeneities in residual stress on the order of 1 GPa in both sets of samples. Scanning transmission electron micrographs reveal straight dislocations aligned along slip bands and interacting with dislocations of other types that act as obstacles. The stress heterogeneities and accumulations of dislocations along their slip planes are consistent with strain hardening resulting from long-range back-stresses acting between dislocations. These results corroborate the mechanical data in supporting the form of the new flow law for low-temperature plasticity and provide new microstructural criteria for identifying the operation of this deformation mechanism in natural samples.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Insight into the microphysics of antigorite deformation from spherical nanoindentation
Authors:
Lars N. Hansen,
Emmanuel C. David,
Nicolas Brantut,
David Wallis
Abstract:
The mechanical behavior of antigorite strongly influences the strength and deformation of the subduction interface. Although there is microstructural evidence elucidating the nature of brittle deformation at low pressures, there is often conflicting evidence regarding the potential for plastic deformation in the ductile regime at higher pressures. Here, we present a series of spherical nanoindenta…
▽ More
The mechanical behavior of antigorite strongly influences the strength and deformation of the subduction interface. Although there is microstructural evidence elucidating the nature of brittle deformation at low pressures, there is often conflicting evidence regarding the potential for plastic deformation in the ductile regime at higher pressures. Here, we present a series of spherical nanoindentation experiments on aggregates of natural antigorite. These experiments effectively investigate the single-crystal mechanical behavior because the volume of deformed material is significantly smaller than the grain size. Individual indents reveal elastic loading followed by yield and strain hardening. The magnitude of the yield stress is a function of crystal orientation, with lower values associated with indents parallel to the basal plane. Unloading paths reveal more strain recovery than expected for purely elastic unloading. The magnitude of inelastic strain recovery is highest for indents parallel to the basal plane. We also imposed indents with cyclical loading paths, and observed strain energy dissipation during unloading-loading cycles conducted up to a fixed maximum indentation load and depth. The magnitude of this dissipated strain energy was highest for indents parallel to the basal plane. Subsequent scanning electron microscopy revealed surface impressions accommodated by shear cracks and a general lack of lattice misorientation around indents, indicating the absence of dislocations. Based on these observations, we suggest that antigorite deformation at high pressures is dominated by sliding on shear cracks. We develop a microphysical model that is able to quantitatively explain the Young's modulus and dissipated strain energy data during cyclic loading experiments, based on either frictional or cohesive sliding of an array of cracks contained in the basal plane.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2019; v1 submitted 20 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
High-angular resolution electron backscatter diffraction as a new tool for mapping lattice distortion in geological minerals
Authors:
David Wallis,
Lars N. Hansen,
T. Ben Britton,
Angus J. Wilkinson
Abstract:
Analysis of distortions of the crystal lattice within individual mineral grains is central to the investigation of microscale processes that control and record tectonic events. These distortions are generally combinations of lattice rotations and elastic strains, but a lack of suitable observational techniques has prevented these components being mapped simultaneously and routinely in earth scienc…
▽ More
Analysis of distortions of the crystal lattice within individual mineral grains is central to the investigation of microscale processes that control and record tectonic events. These distortions are generally combinations of lattice rotations and elastic strains, but a lack of suitable observational techniques has prevented these components being mapped simultaneously and routinely in earth science laboratories. However, the technique of high-angular resolution electron backscatter diffraction (HR-EBSD) provides the opportunity to simultaneously map lattice rotations and elastic strains with exceptional precision, on the order of 0.01 degree for rotations and 10-4 in strain, using a scanning electron microscope. Importantly, these rotations and lattice strains relate to densities of geometrically necessary dislocations and residual stresses. Recent works have begun to apply and adapt HR-EBSD to geological minerals, highlighting the potential of the technique to provide new insights into the microphysics of rock deformation. Therefore, the purpose of this overview is to provide a summary of the technique, to identify caveats and targets for further development, and to suggest areas where it offers potential for major advances. In particular, HREBSD is well suited to characterising the roles of different dislocation types during crystal plastic deformation and to mapping heterogeneous internal stress fields associated with specific deformation mechanisms/microstructures or changes in temperature, confining pressure, or applied deviatoric stress. These capabilities make HR-EBSD a particularly powerful new technique for analysing the microstructures of deformed geological materials.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2019; v1 submitted 17 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Low-Frequency Measurements of Seismic Velocity and Attenuation in Antigorite Serpentinite
Authors:
Emmanuel C. David,
Nicolas Brantut,
Lars N. Hansen,
Ian Jackson
Abstract:
Laboratory measurements of seismic velocity and attenuation in antigorite serpentinite at a confining pressure of $2$ kbar and temperatures up to $550^\circ$C (i.e., in the antigorite stability field) provide new results relevant to the interpretation of geophysical data in subduction zones. A polycrystalline antigorite specimen was tested via forced-oscillations at small strain amplitudes and sei…
▽ More
Laboratory measurements of seismic velocity and attenuation in antigorite serpentinite at a confining pressure of $2$ kbar and temperatures up to $550^\circ$C (i.e., in the antigorite stability field) provide new results relevant to the interpretation of geophysical data in subduction zones. A polycrystalline antigorite specimen was tested via forced-oscillations at small strain amplitudes and seismic frequencies (mHZ--Hz). The shear modulus has a temperature sensitivity, $\partial G/ \partial T$, averaging $-0.017$ GPa K$^{-1}$. Increasing temperature above $500^\circ$C results in more intensive shear attenuation ($Q_G^{-1}$) and associated modulus dispersion, with $Q_G^{-1}$ increasing monotonically with increasing oscillation period and temperature. This "background" relaxation is adequately captured by a Burgers model for viscoelasticity and possibly results from intergranular mechanisms. Attenuation is higher in antigorite ($\log_{10} Q_G^{-1} \approx -1.5$ at $550^\circ$C and $0.01$ Hz than in olivine ($\log_{10} Q_G^{-1} \ll -2.0$ below $800^\circ$C), but such contrast does not appear to be strong enough to allow robust identification of antigorite from seismic models of attenuation only.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Absence of Stress-induced Anisotropy during Brittle Deformation in Antigorite Serpentinite
Authors:
Emmanuel C. David,
Nicolas Brantut,
Lars N. Hansen,
Thomas M. Mitchell
Abstract:
Knowledge of the seismological signature of serpentinites during deformation is fundamental for interpreting seismic observations in subduction zones, but this has yet to be experimentally constrained. We measured compressional and shear wave velocities during brittle deformation in polycrystalline antigorite, at room temperature and varying confining pressures up to 150 MPa. Ultrasonic velocity m…
▽ More
Knowledge of the seismological signature of serpentinites during deformation is fundamental for interpreting seismic observations in subduction zones, but this has yet to be experimentally constrained. We measured compressional and shear wave velocities during brittle deformation in polycrystalline antigorite, at room temperature and varying confining pressures up to 150 MPa. Ultrasonic velocity measurements, at varying directions to the compression axis, were combined with mechanical measurements of axial and volumetric strain, during direct loading and cyclic loading triaxial deformation tests. An additional deformation experiment was conducted on a specimen of Westerly granite for comparison. At all confining pressures, brittle deformation in antigorite is associated with a spectacular absence of stress-induced anisotropy and with no noticeable dependence of wave velocities on axial compressive stress, prior to rock failure. The strength of antigorite samples is comparable to that of granite, but the mechanical behaviour is elastic up to high stress ($\gtrsim80$\% of rock strength) and non-dilatant. Microcracking is only observed in antigorite specimens taken to failure and not in those loaded even at $90-95$\% of their compressive strength. Microcrack damage is extremely localised near the fault and consists of shear microcracks that form exclusively along the cleavage plane of antigorite crystals. Our observations demonstrate that brittle deformation in antigorite occurs entirely by "mode II" shear microcracking. This is all the more remarkable than the preexisting microcrack population in antigorite is comparable to that in granite. The mechanical behaviour and seismic signature of antigorite brittle deformation thus appears to be unique within crystalline rocks.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2019; v1 submitted 23 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
