Exploring the Consistency, Quality and Challenges in Manual and Automated Coding of Free-text Diagnoses from Hospital Outpatient Letters
Authors:
Warren Del-Pinto,
George Demetriou,
Meghna Jani,
Rikesh Patel,
Leanne Gray,
Alex Bulcock,
Niels Peek,
Andrew S. Kanter,
William G Dixon,
Goran Nenadic
Abstract:
Coding of unstructured clinical free-text to produce interoperable structured data is essential to improve direct care, support clinical communication and to enable clinical research.However, manual clinical coding is difficult and time consuming, which motivates the development and use of natural language processing for automated coding. This work evaluates the quality and consistency of both man…
▽ More
Coding of unstructured clinical free-text to produce interoperable structured data is essential to improve direct care, support clinical communication and to enable clinical research.However, manual clinical coding is difficult and time consuming, which motivates the development and use of natural language processing for automated coding. This work evaluates the quality and consistency of both manual and automated clinical coding of diagnoses from hospital outpatient letters. Using 100 randomly selected letters, two human clinicians performed coding of diagnosis lists to SNOMED CT. Automated coding was also performed using IMO's Concept Tagger. A gold standard was constructed by a panel of clinicians from a subset of the annotated diagnoses. This was used to evaluate the quality and consistency of both manual and automated coding via (1) a distance-based metric, treating SNOMED CT as a graph, and (2) a qualitative metric agreed upon by the panel of clinicians. Correlation between the two metrics was also evaluated. Comparing human and computer-generated codes to the gold standard, the results indicate that humans slightly out-performed automated coding, while both performed notably better when there was only a single diagnosis contained in the free-text description. Automated coding was considered acceptable by the panel of clinicians in approximately 90% of cases.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
Post-Newtonian approximation for isolated systems by matched asymptotic expansions I. General structure revisited
Authors:
W. G. Dixon
Abstract:
In recent years post-Newtonian approximations for isolated slowly-moving systems in general relativity have been studied by means of matched asymptotic expansions. A paper by Poujade & Blanchet in 2002 made great progress by effectively reducing the use of such expansions to an algorithmic form. It gave systematic procedures for the development of both near-zone and far-zone asymptotic expansions,…
▽ More
In recent years post-Newtonian approximations for isolated slowly-moving systems in general relativity have been studied by means of matched asymptotic expansions. A paper by Poujade & Blanchet in 2002 made great progress by effectively reducing the use of such expansions to an algorithmic form. It gave systematic procedures for the development of both near-zone and far-zone asymptotic expansions, avoiding the divergent integrals which often bedevilled such methods, and showed that these two expansions could be made to match exactly, a result described there as somewhat remarkable.
This paper revisits that work and shows that there is unfortunately an error in it which invalidates the results of the matching process as given therein. The present paper identifies that error and shows how it may be corrected to give valid matching results. The correction is presented in a redevelopment somewhat different from that of their paper. This shows that far from being somewhat remarkable, it is in fact inevitable that the match is exact. It is indeed remarkable that they could carry both expansions to the point at which matching becomes possible, but if it can be done at all, then the match is necessarily exact.
A companion paper will apply this asymptotic matching to a model problem in which the correct near-zone expansion was obtained by approximation from an exact solution. It will be shown that there is a discrepancy between this expansion and results from the original development of Poujade & Blanchet but that the corrected development presented here reproduces the result of the model problem exactly.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
