-
Limits of Large Language Models in Debating Humans
Authors:
James Flamino,
Mohammed Shahid Modi,
Boleslaw K. Szymanski,
Brendan Cross,
Colton Mikolajczyk
Abstract:
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable promise in their ability to interact proficiently with humans. Subsequently, their potential use as artificial confederates and surrogates in sociological experiments involving conversation is an exciting prospect. But how viable is this idea? This paper endeavors to test the limits of current-day LLMs with a pre-registered study integrating real…
▽ More
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable promise in their ability to interact proficiently with humans. Subsequently, their potential use as artificial confederates and surrogates in sociological experiments involving conversation is an exciting prospect. But how viable is this idea? This paper endeavors to test the limits of current-day LLMs with a pre-registered study integrating real people with LLM agents acting as people. The study focuses on debate-based opinion consensus formation in three environments: humans only, agents and humans, and agents only. Our goal is to understand how LLM agents influence humans, and how capable they are in debating like humans. We find that LLMs can blend in and facilitate human productivity but are less convincing in debate, with their behavior ultimately deviating from human's. We elucidate these primary failings and anticipate that LLMs must evolve further before being viable debaters.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Divide-and-rule policy in the Naming Game
Authors:
Cheng Ma,
Brendan Cross,
Gyorgy Korniss,
Boleslaw K. Szymanski
Abstract:
The Naming Game is a classic model for studying the emergence and evolution of language within a population. In this paper, we extend the traditional Naming Game model to encompass multiple committed opinions and investigate the system dynamics on the complete graph with an arbitrarily large population and random networks of finite size. For the fully connected complete graph, the homogeneous mixi…
▽ More
The Naming Game is a classic model for studying the emergence and evolution of language within a population. In this paper, we extend the traditional Naming Game model to encompass multiple committed opinions and investigate the system dynamics on the complete graph with an arbitrarily large population and random networks of finite size. For the fully connected complete graph, the homogeneous mixing condition enables us to use mean-field theory to analyze the opinion evolution of the system. However, when the number of opinions increases, the number of variables describing the system grows exponentially. To mitigate this, we focus on a special scenario where the largest group of committed agents competes with a motley of committed groups, each of which is smaller than the largest one, while initially, most of uncommitted agents hold one unique opinion. This scenario is chosen for its recurrence in diverse societies and its potential for complexity reduction by unifying agents from smaller committed groups into one category. Our investigation reveals that when the size of the largest committed group reaches the critical threshold, most of uncommitted agents change their beliefs to this opinion, triggering a phase transition. Further, we derive the general formula for the multi-opinion evolution using a recursive approach, enabling investigation into any scenario. Finally, we employ agent-based simulations to reveal the opinion evolution and dominance transition in random graphs. Our results provide insights into the conditions under which the dominant opinion emerges in a population and the factors that influence these conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2024; v1 submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Shifting Polarization and Twitter News Influencers between two U.S. Presidential Elections
Authors:
James Flamino,
Alessandro Galezzi,
Stuart Feldman,
Michael W. Macy,
Brendan Cross,
Zhenkun Zhou,
Matteo Serafino,
Alexandre Bovet,
Hernan A. Makse,
Boleslaw K. Szymanski
Abstract:
Social media are decentralized, interactive, and transformative, empowering users to produce and spread information to influence others. This has changed the dynamics of political communication that were previously dominated by traditional corporate news media. Having hundreds of millions of tweets collected over the 2016 and 2020 U.S. presidential elections gave us a unique opportunity to measure…
▽ More
Social media are decentralized, interactive, and transformative, empowering users to produce and spread information to influence others. This has changed the dynamics of political communication that were previously dominated by traditional corporate news media. Having hundreds of millions of tweets collected over the 2016 and 2020 U.S. presidential elections gave us a unique opportunity to measure the change in polarization and the diffusion of political information. We analyze the diffusion of political information among Twitter users and investigate the change of polarization between these elections and how this change affected the composition and polarization of influencers and their retweeters. We identify "influencers" by their ability to spread information and classify them into those affiliated with a media organization, a political organization, or unaffiliated. Most of the top influencers were affiliated with media organizations during both elections. We found a clear increase from 2016 to 2020 in polarization among influencers and among those whom they influence. Moreover, 75% of the top influencers in 2020 were not present in 2016, demonstrating that such status is difficult to retain. Between 2016 and 2020, 10% of influencers affiliated with media were replaced by center- or right-orientated influencers affiliated with political organizations and unaffiliated influencers.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Supersaturation model for InN PA-MOCVD
Authors:
Zaheer Ahmad,
Mark Vernon,
Garnett B. Cross,
Daniel Deocampo,
Alexander Kozhanov
Abstract:
We developed a thermodynamic supersaturation model for plasma-assisted metalorganic chemical vapor deposition of InN. The model is based on the chemical combination of indium with plasma-generated atomic nitrogen ions. Indium supersaturation was analyzed for InN films grown by PA-MOCVD with varying input flow of indium precursor. Raman spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction, and atomic force microscopy p…
▽ More
We developed a thermodynamic supersaturation model for plasma-assisted metalorganic chemical vapor deposition of InN. The model is based on the chemical combination of indium with plasma-generated atomic nitrogen ions. Indium supersaturation was analyzed for InN films grown by PA-MOCVD with varying input flow of indium precursor. Raman spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction, and atomic force microscopy provided feedback on structural properties and surface morphology of grown films. Growth parameter variation effect on In supersaturation was analyzed. InN films grown at varying growth parameters resulting in the same In supersaturation value exhibit similar structural properties and surface morphology.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Asymptotic resolution bounds of generalized modularity and multi-scale community detection
Authors:
Xiaoyan Lu,
Brendan Cross,
Boleslaw K. Szymanski
Abstract:
The maximization of generalized modularity performs well on networks in which the members of all communities are statistically indistinguishable from each other. However, there is no theory bounding the maximization performance in more realistic networks where edges are heterogeneously distributed within and between communities. Using the random graph properties, we establish asymptotic theoretica…
▽ More
The maximization of generalized modularity performs well on networks in which the members of all communities are statistically indistinguishable from each other. However, there is no theory bounding the maximization performance in more realistic networks where edges are heterogeneously distributed within and between communities. Using the random graph properties, we establish asymptotic theoretical bounds on the resolution parameter for which the generalized modularity maximization performs well. From this new perspective on random graph model, we find the resolution limit of modularity maximization can be explained in a surprisingly simple and straightforward way. Given a network produced by the stochastic block models, the communities for which the resolution parameter is larger than their densities are likely to be spread among multiple clusters, while communities for which the resolution parameter is smaller than their background inter-community edge density will be merged into one large component. Therefore, no suitable resolution parameter exits when the intra-community edge density in a subgraph is lower than the inter-community edge density in some other subgraph. For such networks, we propose a progressive agglomerative heuristic algorithm to detect practically significant communities at multiple scales.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2020; v1 submitted 12 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Boundary flow of viscoelastic polyelectrolyte solutions
Authors:
Chloé Barraud,
Benjamin Cross,
Cyril Picard,
Frédéric Restagno,
Liliane Léger,
Elisabeth Charlaix
Abstract:
We report an investigation of the equilibrium and dynamic properties of polyelectrolyte solutions confined between platinum surfaces with a dynamic Surface Force Apparatus. The polyelectrolyte adsorbs on the surfaces in a dense compact layer bearing a surface charge in good agreement with the theoretical predictions. The flow of the solution on this charged adsorbed layer is probed over four decad…
▽ More
We report an investigation of the equilibrium and dynamic properties of polyelectrolyte solutions confined between platinum surfaces with a dynamic Surface Force Apparatus. The polyelectrolyte adsorbs on the surfaces in a dense compact layer bearing a surface charge in good agreement with the theoretical predictions. The flow of the solution on this charged adsorbed layer is probed over four decades of spatial scales and one decade of frequency by dynamic measurements. At distances larger than the hundredth of nanometers, the flow of the viscoelastic solution is well described by a partial slip boundary condition. We show that the wall slip is quantitatively described by an interfacial friction coefficient, according to the original Navier's formulation, and not by a slip length. At smaller distance the partial slip model overestimates the solution mobility, and we observe the presence of a low viscosity layer coating the surfaces. The viscosity and thickness of this boundary layer are directly resolved, and found to be independent on shear-rate, frequency, and confinement. We discuss the thickness of the low viscosity layer in terms of the structural length of the semi-dilute solution and the Debye length screening the adsorbed layer charge.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Wall slip of complex fluids: interfacial friction or slip length?
Authors:
Benjamin Cross,
Chloé Barraud,
Cyril Picard,
Liliane Léger,
Frédéric Restagno,
Elisabeht Charlaix
Abstract:
Using a dynamic Surface Force Apparatus, we demonstrate that the notion of slip length used to describe the boundary flow of simple liquids, is not appropriate for viscoelastic liquids. Rather, the appropriate description lies in the original Navier's partial slip boundary condition, formulated in terms of an interfacial friction coefficient. We establish an exact analytical expression to extract…
▽ More
Using a dynamic Surface Force Apparatus, we demonstrate that the notion of slip length used to describe the boundary flow of simple liquids, is not appropriate for viscoelastic liquids. Rather, the appropriate description lies in the original Navier's partial slip boundary condition, formulated in terms of an interfacial friction coefficient. We establish an exact analytical expression to extract the interfacial friction coefficient from oscillatory drainage forces between a sphere and a plane, suitable for dynamic SFA or Atomic Force Microscopy non-contact measurements. We use this model to investigate the boundary friction of viscoelastic polymer solutions over 5 decades of film thicknesses and one decade in frequency. The proper use of the original Navier's condition describes accurately the complex hydrodynamic force up to scales of tens of micrometers, with a simple "Newtonian-like" friction coefficient, not frequency dependent, and reflecting closely the dynamics of an interfacial depletion layer at the solution/solid interface.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2018; v1 submitted 9 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
A temperature-controlled device for volumetric measurements of Helium adsorption in porous media
Authors:
Benjamin Cross,
Laurent Puech,
Pierre-Etienne Wolf
Abstract:
We describe a set-up for studying adsorption of helium in silica aerogels, where the adsorbed amount is easily and precisely controlled by varying the temperature of a gas reservoir between 80 K and 180 K. We present validation experiments and a first application to aerogels. This device is well adapted to study hysteresis, relaxation, and metastable states in the adsorption and desorption of fl…
▽ More
We describe a set-up for studying adsorption of helium in silica aerogels, where the adsorbed amount is easily and precisely controlled by varying the temperature of a gas reservoir between 80 K and 180 K. We present validation experiments and a first application to aerogels. This device is well adapted to study hysteresis, relaxation, and metastable states in the adsorption and desorption of fluids in porous media.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
-
Evidence for a disorder driven phase transition in the condensation of 4He in aerogels
Authors:
Fabien Bonnet,
Thierry Lambert,
Benjamin Cross,
Laurent Guyon,
Florence Despetis,
Laurent Puech,
Pierre-Etienne Wolf
Abstract:
We report on thermodynamic and optical measurements of the condensation process of $^4$He in three silica aerogels of different microstructures. For the two base-catalysed aerogels, the temperature dependence of the shape of adsorption isotherms and of the morphology of the condensation process show evidence of a disorder driven transition, in agreement with recent theoretical predictions. This…
▽ More
We report on thermodynamic and optical measurements of the condensation process of $^4$He in three silica aerogels of different microstructures. For the two base-catalysed aerogels, the temperature dependence of the shape of adsorption isotherms and of the morphology of the condensation process show evidence of a disorder driven transition, in agreement with recent theoretical predictions. This transition is not observed for a neutral-catalysed aerogel, which we interpret as due to a larger disorder in this case.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2008;
originally announced February 2008.
