Showing 1–47 of 47 results for author: Bhattacharya, S S

Local Inaccessibility of Random Classical Information : Conditional Nonlocality demands Entanglement

Authors: Subhendu B. Ghosh, Snehasish Roy Chowdhury, Tathagata Gupta, Anandamay Das Bhowmik, Sutapa Saha, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Tamal Guha

Abstract: Discrimination of quantum states under local operations and classical communication (LOCC) is an intriguing question in the context of local retrieval of classical information, encoded in the multipartite quantum systems. All the local quantum state discrimination premises, considered so far, mimic a basic communication set-up, where the spatially separated decoding devices are independent of any… ▽ More Discrimination of quantum states under local operations and classical communication (LOCC) is an intriguing question in the context of local retrieval of classical information, encoded in the multipartite quantum systems. All the local quantum state discrimination premises, considered so far, mimic a basic communication set-up, where the spatially separated decoding devices are independent of any additional input. Here, exploring a generalized communication scenario we introduce a framework for input-dependent local quantum state discrimination, which we call local random authentication (LRA). Referring to the term nonlocality, often used to indicate the impossibility of local state discrimination, we coin the term conditional nonlocality for the impossibility associated with the task LRA. We report that conditional nonlocality necessitates the presence of entangled states in the ensemble, a feature absent from erstwhile nonlocality arguments based on local state discrimination. Conversely, all the states in a complete basis set being entangled implies conditional nonlocality. However, the impossibility of LRA also exhibits more conditional nonlocality with less entanglement. The relation between the possibility of LRA and local state discrimination for sets of multipartite quantum states, both in the perfect and conclusive cases, has also been established. The results highlight a completely new aspect of the interplay between the security of information in a network and quantum entanglement under the LOCC paradigm. △ Less

Submitted 19 February, 2024; v1 submitted 17 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: Few lines are added in the discussion section

Unbounded Quantum Advantage in One-Way Strong Communication Complexity of a Distributed Clique Labelling Relation

Authors: Sumit Rout, Nitica Sakharwade, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Ravishankar Ramanathan, Paweł Horodecki

Abstract: We investigate the one-way zero-error classical and quantum communication complexities for a class of relations induced by a distributed clique labelling problem. We consider two variants: 1) the receiver outputs an answer satisfying the relation - the traditional communication complexity of relations (CCR) and 2) the receiver has non-zero probabilities of outputting every valid answer satisfying… ▽ More We investigate the one-way zero-error classical and quantum communication complexities for a class of relations induced by a distributed clique labelling problem. We consider two variants: 1) the receiver outputs an answer satisfying the relation - the traditional communication complexity of relations (CCR) and 2) the receiver has non-zero probabilities of outputting every valid answer satisfying the relation (equivalently, the relation can be fully reconstructed), that we denote the strong communication complexity of the relation (S-CCR). We prove that for the specific class of relations considered here when the players do not share any resources, there is no quantum advantage in the CCR task for any graph. On the other hand, we show that there exist, classes of graphs for which the separation between one-way classical and quantum communication in the S-CCR task grow with the order of the graph $m$, specifically, the quantum complexity is $O(1)$ while the classical complexity is $Ω(\log m)$. Secondly, we prove a lower bound (that is linear in the number of cliques) on the amount of shared randomness necessary to overcome the separation in the scenario of fixed restricted communication and connect this to the existence of Orthogonal Arrays. Finally, we highlight some applications of this task to semi-device-independent dimension witnessing as well as to the detection of Mutually Unbiased Bases. △ Less

Submitted 26 July, 2023; v1 submitted 17 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: Version 2 submission, an improvement of the first pre-print version, this version is submitted to PRX. 27 pages, 9 figures, 7 tables

Randomness-free Test of Non-classicality: a Proof of Concept

Authors: Zhonghua Ma, Markus Rambach, Kaumudibikash Goswami, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Manik Banik, Jacquiline Romero

Abstract: Quantum correlations and non-projective measurements underlie a plethora of information-theoretic tasks, otherwise impossible in the classical world. Existing schemes to certify such non-classical resources in a device-independent manner require seed randomness, which is often costly and vulnerable to loopholes, for choosing the local measurements performed on different parts of a multipartite qua… ▽ More Quantum correlations and non-projective measurements underlie a plethora of information-theoretic tasks, otherwise impossible in the classical world. Existing schemes to certify such non-classical resources in a device-independent manner require seed randomness, which is often costly and vulnerable to loopholes, for choosing the local measurements performed on different parts of a multipartite quantum system. In this letter, we propose and experimentally implement a semi-device independent certification technique for both quantum correlations and non-projective measurements without seed randomness. Our test is semi-device independent in the sense that it requires only prior knowledge of the dimensions of the parts. We experimentally show a novel quantum advantage in correlated coin tossing by producing specific correlated coins from pairs of photons entangled in their transverse spatial modes. We establish the advantage by showing that the correlated coin obtained from the entangled photons cannot be obtained from two 2-level classical correlated coins. The quantum advantage requires performing qubit trine positive operator-valued measures (POVMs) on each part of the entangled pair, thus also certifying such POVMs in a semi-device-independent manner. This proof of concept firmly establishes a new cost-effective certification technique for both generating non-classical shared randomness and implementing non-classical measurements, which will be important for future multi-party quantum communications. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2023; v1 submitted 13 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: Accepted in PRL. This is the accepted version

Classical analogue of quantum superdense coding and communication advantage of a single quantum system

Authors: Ram Krishna Patra, Sahil Gopalkrishna Naik, Edwin Peter Lobo, Samrat Sen, Tamal Guha, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Mir Alimuddin, Manik Banik

Abstract: We analyze utility of communication channels in absence of any short of quantum or classical correlation shared between the sender and the receiver. To this aim, we propose a class of two-party communication games, and show that the games cannot be won given a noiseless $1$-bit classical channel from the sender to the receiver. Interestingly, the goal can be perfectly achieved if the channel is as… ▽ More We analyze utility of communication channels in absence of any short of quantum or classical correlation shared between the sender and the receiver. To this aim, we propose a class of two-party communication games, and show that the games cannot be won given a noiseless $1$-bit classical channel from the sender to the receiver. Interestingly, the goal can be perfectly achieved if the channel is assisted with classical shared randomness. This resembles an advantage similar to the quantum superdense coding phenomenon where pre-shared entanglement can enhance the communication utility of a perfect quantum communication line. Quite surprisingly, we show that a qubit communication without any assistance of classical shared randomness can achieve the goal, and hence establishes a novel quantum advantage in the simplest communication scenario. In pursuit of a deeper origin of this advantage, we show that an advantageous quantum strategy must invoke quantum interference both at the encoding step by the sender and at the decoding step by the receiver. We also study communication utility of a class of non-classical toy systems described by symmetric polygonal state spaces. We come up with communication tasks that can be achieved neither with $1$-bit of classical communication nor by communicating a polygon system, whereas $1$-qubit communication yields a perfect strategy, establishing quantum advantage over them. To this end, we show that the quantum advantages are robust against imperfect encodings-decodings, making the protocols implementable with presently available quantum technologies. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2024; v1 submitted 14 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: Single column, 39 pages, 15 figures; Accepted in Quantum

Journal ref: Quantum 8, 1315 (2024)

Local Quantum State Marking

Authors: Samrat Sen, Edwin Peter Lobo, Sahil Gopalkrishna Naik, Ram Krishna Patra, Tathagata Gupta, Subhendu B. Ghosh, Sutapa Saha, Mir Alimuddin, Tamal Guha, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Manik Banik

Abstract: We propose the task of local state marking (LSM), where some multipartite quantum states chosen randomly from a known set of states are distributed among spatially separated parties without revealing the identities of the individual states. The collaborative aim of the parties is to correctly mark the identities of states under the restriction that they can perform only local quantum operations (L… ▽ More We propose the task of local state marking (LSM), where some multipartite quantum states chosen randomly from a known set of states are distributed among spatially separated parties without revealing the identities of the individual states. The collaborative aim of the parties is to correctly mark the identities of states under the restriction that they can perform only local quantum operations (LO) on their respective subsystems and can communicate with each other classically (CC) -- popularly known as the operational paradigm of LOCC. While mutually orthogonal states can always be marked exactly under global operations, this is in general not the case under LOCC. We show that the LSM task is distinct from the vastly explored task of local state distinguishability (LSD) -- perfect LSD always implies perfect LSM, whereas we establish that the converse does not hold in general. We also explore entanglement assisted marking of states that are otherwise locally unmarkable and report intriguing entanglement assisted catalytic LSM phenomenon. △ Less

Submitted 7 March, 2022; v1 submitted 26 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: Closed to published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 105, 032407 (2022)

Composition of multipartite quantum systems: perspective from time-like paradigm

Authors: Sahil Gopalkrishna Naik, Edwin Peter Lobo, Samrat Sen, Ramkrishna Patra, Mir Alimuddin, Tamal Guha, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Manik Banik

Abstract: Figuring out the physical rationale behind natural selection of quantum theory is one of the most acclaimed quests in quantum foundational research. This pursuit has inspired several axiomatic initiatives to derive mathematical formulation of the theory by identifying general structure of state and effect space of individual systems as well as specifying their composition rules. This generic frame… ▽ More Figuring out the physical rationale behind natural selection of quantum theory is one of the most acclaimed quests in quantum foundational research. This pursuit has inspired several axiomatic initiatives to derive mathematical formulation of the theory by identifying general structure of state and effect space of individual systems as well as specifying their composition rules. This generic framework can allow several consistent composition rules for a multipartite system even when state and effect cones of individual subsystems are assumed to be quantum. Nevertheless, for any bipartite system, none of these compositions allows beyond quantum space-like correlations. In this letter we show that such bipartite compositions can admit stronger than quantum correlations in the time-like domain and, hence, indicates pragmatically distinct roles carried out by state and effect cones. We discuss consequences of such correlations in a communication task, which accordingly opens up a possibility of testing the actual composition between elementary quanta. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2022; v1 submitted 19 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: Accepted in Physical Review Letters (close to accepted version)

Complete crystallographic, spin-electronic and magnetic structure of (Co0.2Cr0.2Fe0.2Mn0.2Ni0.2)3O4: Unraveling the suppression of entropy in high entropy oxides

Authors: Abhishek Sarkar, Benedikt Eggert, Ralf Witte, Johanna Lill, Leonardo Velasco, Qingsong Wang, Janhavika Sonar, Katharina Ollefs, Subramshu S. Bhattacharya, Richard A. Brand, Heiko Wende, Frank M. F. de Groot, Oliver Clemens, Horst Hahn, Robert Kruk

Abstract: High entropy oxides (HEOs) are a rapidly emerging class of functional materials consisting of multiple principal cations. The original paradigm of HEOs assumes cationic occupations with the highest possible configurational entropy allowed by the composition and crystallographic structure. However, the fundamental question remains on the actual degree of configurational disorder in HEOs, especially… ▽ More High entropy oxides (HEOs) are a rapidly emerging class of functional materials consisting of multiple principal cations. The original paradigm of HEOs assumes cationic occupations with the highest possible configurational entropy allowed by the composition and crystallographic structure. However, the fundamental question remains on the actual degree of configurational disorder in HEOs, especially, in systems with a low enthalpy barriers for cation anti-site mixing. Considering the experimental limitations due to the presence of multiple principal cations in HEOs, here we utilize a robust and cross-referenced characterization approach using soft X-ray magnetic circular dichroism, hard X-ray absorption spectroscopy, Mössbauer spectroscopy, neutron powder diffraction and SQUID magnetometry to study the competition between crystal field stabilization energy and configurational entropy governing the cation occupation in a spinel HEO (S-HEO), (Co$_{0.2}$Cr$_{0.2}$Fe$_{0.2}$Mn$_{0.2}$Ni$_{0.2}$)$_3$O$_4$. In contrast to the previous studies, the derived complete structural and spin-electronic model, (Co$_{0.6}$Fe$_{0.4}$)(Cr$_{0.3}$Fe$_{0.1}$Mn$_{0.3}$Ni$_{0.3}$)$_2$O$_4$, highlights a significant deviation from the hitherto assumed paradigm of entropy-driven non-preferential distribution of cations in HEOs. An immediate correlation of this result can be drawn with bulk as well as the local element specific magnetic properties, which are intrinsically dictated by cationic occupations in spinels. The real local lattice picture presented here provides an alternate viewpoint on ionic arrangement in HEOs, which is of fundamental interest for predicting and designing their structure-dependent functionalities. △ Less

Submitted 22 December, 2021; v1 submitted 9 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Random-Receiver Quantum Communication

Authors: Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Ananda G. Maity, Tamal Guha, Giulio Chiribella, Manik Banik

Abstract: We introduce the task of random-receiver quantum communication, in which a sender transmits a quantum message to a receiver chosen from a list of n spatially separated parties. The choice of receiver is unknown to the sender, but is known by the n parties, who coordinate their actions by exchanging classical messages. In normal conditions, random-receiver quantum communication requires a noiseless… ▽ More We introduce the task of random-receiver quantum communication, in which a sender transmits a quantum message to a receiver chosen from a list of n spatially separated parties. The choice of receiver is unknown to the sender, but is known by the n parties, who coordinate their actions by exchanging classical messages. In normal conditions, random-receiver quantum communication requires a noiseless quantum communication channel from the sender to each of the n receivers. In contrast, we show that random-receiver quantum communication can take place through entanglement-breaking channels if the order of such channels is controlled by a quantum bit that is accessible through quantum measurements. Notably, this phenomenon cannot be mimicked by allowing free quantum communication between the sender and any subset of k<n parties. △ Less

Submitted 31 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 11 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: PRX Quantum 2, 020350 (2021)

Quantum theory is exclusive: a distributed computing setup

Authors: Sutapa Saha, Tamal Guha, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Manik Banik

Abstract: The framework of distributed computing, consisting of several spatially separated input-output servers, has immense importance in distant data manipulation. One of the most challenging parts of this setting is to optimize the use of information transmission lines among distant servers. In this work, we have modeled such a physically motivated distributed computing setup for which quantum communica… ▽ More The framework of distributed computing, consisting of several spatially separated input-output servers, has immense importance in distant data manipulation. One of the most challenging parts of this setting is to optimize the use of information transmission lines among distant servers. In this work, we have modeled such a physically motivated distributed computing setup for which quantum communication outperforms its classical counterpart, in terms of a limited usage of noiseless transmission lines. Moreover, a broader class of communication entities, that allow state-effect description more exotic than quantum and are described within the framework of generalized probabilistic theory, also fail to meet the strength of quantum theory. The computational strength of quantum communication has further been justified in terms of a stronger version of this task, namely the delayed-choice distributed computation. The proposed task thus provides a new approach to operationally single out quantum theory in the theory-space and hence promises a novel perspective towards the axiomatic derivation of Hilbert space quantum mechanics. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2023; v1 submitted 10 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: Comments are welcome

Multi-copy adaptive local discrimination: Strongest possible two-qubit nonlocal bases

Authors: Manik Banik, Tamal Guha, Mir Alimuddin, Guruprasad Kar, Saronath Halder, Some Sankar Bhattacharya

Abstract: Ensembles of composite quantum states can exhibit nonlocal behaviour in the sense that their optimal discrimination may require global operations. Such an ensemble containing N pairwise orthogonal pure states, however, can always be perfectly distinguished under adaptive local scheme if (N-1) copies of the state are available. In this letter, we provide examples of orthonormal bases in two-qubit H… ▽ More Ensembles of composite quantum states can exhibit nonlocal behaviour in the sense that their optimal discrimination may require global operations. Such an ensemble containing N pairwise orthogonal pure states, however, can always be perfectly distinguished under adaptive local scheme if (N-1) copies of the state are available. In this letter, we provide examples of orthonormal bases in two-qubit Hilbert space whose adaptive discrimination require 3 copies of the state. For this composite system we analyze multi-copy adaptive local distinguishability of orthogonal ensembles in full generality which in turn assigns varying nonlocal strength to different such ensembles. We also come up with ensembles whose discrimination under adaptive separable scheme require less number of copies than adaptive local schemes. Our construction finds important application in multipartite secret sharing tasks and indicates towards an intriguing super-additivity phenomenon for locally accessible information. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2021; v1 submitted 18 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: Accepted in Physical Review Letters

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 210505 (2021)

Antiferromagnetism in a nanocrystalline high entropy oxide (Co,Cu,Mg,Ni,Zn)O : Magnetic constituents and surface anisotropy leading to lattice distortion

Authors: Nandhini J. Usharani, Anikesh Bhandarkar, Sankaran Subramanian, Subramshu S. Bhattacharya

Abstract: For the first time, this study shows that distortion in a crystal structure due to magnetic effect is possible in a lattice with extreme chemical disorder. The multicomponent equimolar transition metal oxide (ME TMO), (Co,Cu,Mg,Ni,Zn)O, which is a high entropy oxide, has been attracting a lot of attention due to its unique application potential in many fields including electrochemical energy stora… ▽ More For the first time, this study shows that distortion in a crystal structure due to magnetic effect is possible in a lattice with extreme chemical disorder. The multicomponent equimolar transition metal oxide (ME TMO), (Co,Cu,Mg,Ni,Zn)O, which is a high entropy oxide, has been attracting a lot of attention due to its unique application potential in many fields including electrochemical energy storage. In the present investigation, nanocrystalline ME TMO was synthesised by three bottom up methods. The presence of distortion in the rocksalt crystal structure, revealed by X ray diffraction and Raman spectroscopy, and correlated with magnetic measurements from SQUID and EPR studies could be attributed to the additive effects of exchange striction (from the magnetic constituents) and magnetic anisotropy (from the decreased crystallite size). For the first time, iron has been doped into ME TMO, to show that a higher amount of magnetic constituent increases the distortion in the lattice. Nanocrystalline ME TMO also showed a core shell magnetic behavior below the bifurcation temperature arising from the uncompensated or canted spin at the surface. Neel temperature of the nanocrystalline ME TMO is reported for first time to be as high as 700 K. This study helps unravel the structure and magnetic properties of such high entropy materials, and augurs a definite scope for better understanding of the factors influencing the crystal structure in high entropy oxides. △ Less

Submitted 24 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 11 pages, 10 figures

Role of intermediate 4$f$ states in tuning the band structure of high entropy oxides

Authors: Abhishek Sarkar, Benedikt Eggert, Leonardo Velasco, Xiaoke Mu, Johanna Lill, Katharina Ollefs, Subramshu S. Bhattacharya, Heiko Wende, Robert Kruk, Richard A. Brand, Horst Hahn

Abstract: High entropy oxides (HEOs) are single phase solid solutions consisting of 5 or more cations in approximately equiatomic proportions. In this study, we show reversible control of optical properties in a rare-earth (RE) based HEO-(Ce$_{0.2}$La$_{0.2}$Pr$_{0.2}$Sm$_{0.2}$Y$_{0.2}$)O$_{2-δ}$ and subsequently utilize a combination of spectroscopic techniques to derive the features of the electronic ban… ▽ More High entropy oxides (HEOs) are single phase solid solutions consisting of 5 or more cations in approximately equiatomic proportions. In this study, we show reversible control of optical properties in a rare-earth (RE) based HEO-(Ce$_{0.2}$La$_{0.2}$Pr$_{0.2}$Sm$_{0.2}$Y$_{0.2}$)O$_{2-δ}$ and subsequently utilize a combination of spectroscopic techniques to derive the features of the electronic band structure underpinning the observed optical phenomena. Heat treatment of the HEO under vacuum atmosphere followed by reheat-treatment in air results in a reversible change of the band gap energy, from 1.9 eV to 2.5 eV. The finding is consistent with the reversible changes in the oxidation state and related $f$-orbital occupancy of Pr. However, no pertinent changes in the phase composition or crystal structure is observed upon the vacuum heat treatment. Further annealing of this HEO under H$_2$ atmosphere, followed by reheat-treatment in air, results in even larger but still reversible change of the band gap energy from 1.9 eV to 3.2 eV. This is accompanied by a disorder-order type crystal structure transition and changes in the O 2$p$-RE 5$d$ hybridization evidenced from X-ray absorption near edge spectra (XANES). The O $K$ and RE ${M_{4,5}}$/$L_{3}$ XANES indicate that the presence of Ce and Pr (in 3+/4+) state leads to the formation of intermediate 4$f$ energy levels between the O 2$p$ and RE 5$d$ gap in HEO. It is concluded that heat treatment under reducing/oxidizing atmospheres affects these intermediate levels, thus, offering the possibility to tune the band gap energy in HEO. △ Less

Submitted 29 February, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Quantum Advantage for Shared Randomness Generation

Authors: Tamal Guha, Mir Alimuddin, Sumit Rout, Amit Mukherjee, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Manik Banik

Abstract: Sharing correlated random variables is a resource for a number of information theoretic tasks such as privacy amplification, simultaneous message passing, secret sharing and many more. In this article, we show that to establish such a resource called shared randomness, quantum systems provide an advantage over their classical counterpart. Precisely, we show that appropriate albeit fixed measuremen… ▽ More Sharing correlated random variables is a resource for a number of information theoretic tasks such as privacy amplification, simultaneous message passing, secret sharing and many more. In this article, we show that to establish such a resource called shared randomness, quantum systems provide an advantage over their classical counterpart. Precisely, we show that appropriate albeit fixed measurements on a shared two-qubit state can generate correlations which cannot be obtained from any possible state on two classical bits. In a resource theoretic set-up, this feature of quantum systems can be interpreted as an advantage in winning a two players co-operative game, which we call the `non-monopolize social subsidy' game. It turns out that the quantum states leading to the desired advantage must possess non-classicality in the form of quantum discord. On the other hand, while distributing such sources of shared randomness between two parties via noisy channels, quantum channels with zero capacity as well as with classical capacity strictly less than unity perform more efficiently than the perfect classical channel. Protocols presented here are noise-robust and hence should be realizable with state-of-the-art quantum devices. △ Less

Submitted 22 October, 2021; v1 submitted 7 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Comments: Accepted in Quantum

Journal ref: Quantum 5, 569 (2021)

Nonlocality Without Entanglement: Quantum Theory and Beyond

Authors: Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Sutapa Saha, Tamal Guha, Manik Banik

Abstract: Quantum nonlocality without entanglement (Q-NWE) encapsulates nonlocal behavior of multipartite product states as they may entail global operation for optimal decoding of the classical information encoded within. Here we show that the phenomena of NWE is not specific to quantum theory only, rather a class of generalized probabilistic theories can exhibit such behavior. In fact several manifestatio… ▽ More Quantum nonlocality without entanglement (Q-NWE) encapsulates nonlocal behavior of multipartite product states as they may entail global operation for optimal decoding of the classical information encoded within. Here we show that the phenomena of NWE is not specific to quantum theory only, rather a class of generalized probabilistic theories can exhibit such behavior. In fact several manifestations of NWE, e.g., asymmetric local discrimination, suboptimal local discrimination, notion of separable but locally unimplementable measurement arise generically in operational theories other than quantum theory. We propose a framework to compare the strength of NWE in different theories and show that such behavior in quantum theory is limited, suggesting a specific topological feature of quantum theory, namely, the continuity of state space structure. Our work adds profound foundational appeal to the study of NWE phenomena along with its information theoretic relevance. △ Less

Submitted 28 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 5+6 pages, Comments are welcome

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 2, 012068 (2020)

The principle of information symmetry constrains the state-space in any physical theory

Authors: Manik Banik, Sutapa Saha, Tamal Guha, Sristy Agrawal, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Arup Roy, A. S. Majumdar

Abstract: Symmetry shares an entwined history with the structure of physical theory. We propose a consequence of symmetry towards the axiomatic derivation of Hilbert space quantum theory. We introduce the notion of information symmetry (IS) and show that it constraints the state-space structure in any physical theory. To this end, we study the minimal error binary state discrimination problem in the framewo… ▽ More Symmetry shares an entwined history with the structure of physical theory. We propose a consequence of symmetry towards the axiomatic derivation of Hilbert space quantum theory. We introduce the notion of information symmetry (IS) and show that it constraints the state-space structure in any physical theory. To this end, we study the minimal error binary state discrimination problem in the framework of generalized probabilistic theories. A theory is said to satisfy IS if the probability of incorrectly identifying each of two randomly prepared states is same for both the states. It is found that this simple principle rules out several classes of theories while being perfectly compatible with quantum theory. △ Less

Submitted 8 December, 2019; v1 submitted 22 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: Accepted in Physical Review A (Rapid Communications); Close to accepted version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 100, 060101 (2019)

Indefinite causal order enables perfect quantum communication with zero capacity channels

Authors: Giulio Chiribella, Manik Banik, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Tamal Guha, Mir Alimuddin, Arup Roy, Sutapa Saha, Sristy Agrawal, Guruprasad Kar

Abstract: Quantum mechanics is compatible with scenarios where the relative order between two events can be indefinite. Here we show that two independent instances of a noisy process can behave as a perfect quantum communication channel when used in a coherent superposition of two alternative orders. This phenomenon occurs even if the original process has zero capacity to transmit quantum information. In co… ▽ More Quantum mechanics is compatible with scenarios where the relative order between two events can be indefinite. Here we show that two independent instances of a noisy process can behave as a perfect quantum communication channel when used in a coherent superposition of two alternative orders. This phenomenon occurs even if the original process has zero capacity to transmit quantum information. In contrast, perfect quantum communication does not occur when the message is sent directly from the sender to the receiver through a superposition of alternative paths, with an independent noise process acting on each path. The possibility of perfect quantum communication through independent noisy channels highlights a fundamental difference between the superposition of orders in time and the superposition of paths in space. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2022; v1 submitted 24 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 10+12 pages, Significantly expanded version with new results and a new figure. Accepted in New Journal of Physics

Journal ref: New Journal of Physics 23, 033039 (2021)

Sharing of tripartite nonlocality by multiple observers measuring sequentially at one side

Authors: Sutapa Saha, Debarshi Das, Souradeep Sasmal, Debasis Sarkar, Kaushiki Mukherjee, Arup Roy, Some Sankar Bhattacharya

Abstract: Standard tripartite nonlocality and genuine tripartite nonlocality can be detected by the violations of Mermin inequality and Svetlichny inequality, respectively. Since tripartite quantum nonlocality has novel applications in quantum information and quantum computation, it is important to investigate whether more than three observers can share tripartite nonlocality, simultaneously. In the present… ▽ More Standard tripartite nonlocality and genuine tripartite nonlocality can be detected by the violations of Mermin inequality and Svetlichny inequality, respectively. Since tripartite quantum nonlocality has novel applications in quantum information and quantum computation, it is important to investigate whether more than three observers can share tripartite nonlocality, simultaneously. In the present study we answer this question in the affirmative. In particular, we consider a scenario where three spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ particles are spatially separated and shared between Alice, Bob and multiple Charlies. Alice performs measurements on the first particle; Bob performs measurements on the second particle and multiple Charlies perform measurements on the third particle sequentially. In this scenario we investigate how many Charlies can simultaneously demonstrate standard tripartite nonlocality and genuine tripartite nonlocality with single Alice and single Bob. The interesting result revealed by the present study is that at most six Charlies can simultaneously demonstrate standard tripartite nonlocality with single Alice and single Bob. On the other hand, at most two Charlies can simultaneously demonstrate genuine tripartite nonlocality with single Alice and single Bob. Hence, the present study shows that standard tripartite nonlocality can be simultaneously shared by larger number of Charlies compared to genuine tripartite nonlocality in the aforementioned scenario, which implies that standard tripartite nonlocality is more effective than genuine tripartite nonlocality in the context of simultaneous sharing by multiple observers. △ Less

Submitted 1 January, 2019; v1 submitted 23 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: Close to published version. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1811.04813

Journal ref: Quantum Inf Process (2019) 18: 42

Environmental effects on nonlocal correlations

Authors: Tamal Guha, Bihalan Bhattacharya, Debarshi Das, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy, Kaushiki Mukherjee, Nirman Ganguly, A. S. Majumdar

Abstract: Environmental interactions are ubiquitous in practical instances of any quantum information processing protocol. The interaction results in depletion of various quantum resources and even complete loss in numerous situations. Nonlocality, which is one particular quantum resource marking a significant departure of quantum mechanics from classical mechanics, meets the same fate. In the present work… ▽ More Environmental interactions are ubiquitous in practical instances of any quantum information processing protocol. The interaction results in depletion of various quantum resources and even complete loss in numerous situations. Nonlocality, which is one particular quantum resource marking a significant departure of quantum mechanics from classical mechanics, meets the same fate. In the present work we study the decay in nonlocality to the extent of the output state admitting a local hidden state model. Using some fundamental quantum channels we also demonstrate the complete decay in the resources in the purview of the Bell-CHSH inequality and a 3-settings steering inequality. We also obtain bounds on the parameter of the depolarizing map for which it becomes steerability breaking pertaining to a general class of two qubit states. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2019; v1 submitted 4 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: Accepted in Quanta. Accepted version

Journal ref: Quanta , Volume 8 , Page 57, 2019

Advantage of Quantum Theory Over Non-classical Models of Communication

Authors: Sutapa Saha, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Tamal Guha, Saronath Halder, Manik Banik

Abstract: Quantum correlations provide dramatic advantage over the corresponding classical resources in several communication tasks. However a broad class of probabilistic theories exists that attributes greater success than quantum theory in many of these tasks by allowing supra-quantum correlations in `space-like' and/or `time-like' paradigms. In this letter we propose a communication task involving three… ▽ More Quantum correlations provide dramatic advantage over the corresponding classical resources in several communication tasks. However a broad class of probabilistic theories exists that attributes greater success than quantum theory in many of these tasks by allowing supra-quantum correlations in `space-like' and/or `time-like' paradigms. In this letter we propose a communication task involving three spatially separated parties where one party (verifier) aims to verify whether the bit strings possessed by the other two parties (terminals) are equal or not. We call this task {\it authentication with limited communication}, the restrictions on communication being: (i) the terminals cannot communicate with each other, but (ii) each of them can communicate with the verifier through single use of channels with limited capacity. Manifestly, classical resources are not sufficient for perfect success of this task. Moreover, it is also not possible to perform this task with certainty in several non-classical theories although they might possess stronger `space-like' and/or `time-like' correlations. Surprisingly quantum resources can achieve the perfect winning strategy. The proposed task thus stands apart from all previously known communication tasks as it exhibits quantum advantage over other non-classical strategies. △ Less

Submitted 5 November, 2020; v1 submitted 25 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: Close to accepted version

Journal ref: Ann. Phys. (Berlin) 2020, 2000334

Uncertainty principle as post-quantum nonlocality witness for continuous variable multi-mode scenario

Authors: Prathik J Cherian, Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Manik Banik

Abstract: Uncertainty principle is one of the central concepts in quantum theory. Different forms of this particular principle have been discoursed in various foundational and information theoretic topics. In the discrete input-output scenario the limited nonlocal behavior of quantum theory has been explained by fine-grained uncertainty relation. On the other hand, in continuous variable paradigm Robertson-… ▽ More Uncertainty principle is one of the central concepts in quantum theory. Different forms of this particular principle have been discoursed in various foundational and information theoretic topics. In the discrete input-output scenario the limited nonlocal behavior of quantum theory has been explained by fine-grained uncertainty relation. On the other hand, in continuous variable paradigm Robertson-Schrodinger (RS) uncertainty relation has been used to detect multi-mode entanglement. Here we show that RS uncertainty relation plays an important role to discriminate between quantum and post-quantum nonlocal correlations in multi-mode continuous outcome scenario. We provide a class of m-mode post-quantum nonlocal correlations with continuous outcome spectrum. While nonlocality of the introduced class of correlations is established through Calvalcanti-Foster-Reid-Drummond (CFRD) class of Bell inequalities, RS uncertainty relation detects their post-quantum nature. Our result is a hint towards a wider role of uncertainty principle in the study of nonlocality in continuous variable multi-mode systems. △ Less

Submitted 21 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 10 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 99, 012105 (2019)

Analytical construction of non local operator for n-qubit Dicke state

Authors: Sutapa Saha, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Arup Roy, Amit Mukherjee, Ramij Rahaman

Abstract: Entanglement in multipartite quantum systems is much more elusive than its bipartite counterpart. In recent past the usefulness of multipartite entangled states in several information theoretic tasks have been demonstrated. Being a resource, the detection of multipartite entanglement is an imperative necessity. Among the different classes of multipartite entangled states the Dicke state has found… ▽ More Entanglement in multipartite quantum systems is much more elusive than its bipartite counterpart. In recent past the usefulness of multipartite entangled states in several information theoretic tasks have been demonstrated. Being a resource, the detection of multipartite entanglement is an imperative necessity. Among the different classes of multipartite entangled states the Dicke state has found importance in several tasks due to its permutation symmetric nature. In this work we propose a simple and elegant way of detecting n qubit Dicke states using permutation symmetric Bell operators. We conjecture that maximal expectation value of the operator corresponds to the detection of Dicke states. △ Less

Submitted 1 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: Single Column

Thermodynamics of local baths in the context of work extraction

Authors: Tamal Guha, Mir Alimuddin, Amit Mukherjee, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Arup Roy, Arpan Bhattacharyya

Abstract: We consider locally thermal states (for two qubits) with certain amount of quantum entanglement present between them. Unlike previous protocols we show how work can be extracted by performing local unitary operations on this state by allowing those two qubits to interact with thermal baths of different temperatures, thereby gradually removing the entanglement between them till they reach a direct… ▽ More We consider locally thermal states (for two qubits) with certain amount of quantum entanglement present between them. Unlike previous protocols we show how work can be extracted by performing local unitary operations on this state by allowing those two qubits to interact with thermal baths of different temperatures, thereby gradually removing the entanglement between them till they reach a direct product state. Also we demonstrate that, further work can be extracted from this direct product state by performing global unitary operation, thereby establishing that work can be extracted from a system composed of locally thermal subsystems even after removing quantum correlations between them if the subsystems are thermalized at different temperatures. Also we show that even if we consider a initial state where there is no entanglement between the two qubits, we can also extract work locally using our method. △ Less

Submitted 31 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: 8 pages, 2 figures

Report number: YITP-17-95

Several Trade off Features of Quantum Steering in Distributed Scenario

Authors: Arup Roy, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Amit Mukherjee, Nirman Ganguly, Biswajit Paul, Kaushiki Mukherjee

Abstract: In the present work, we address the question of how bipartite steering violation takes place among multi-partite systems (where each sub-system have Hilbert space dimension restricted to two) based on the maximal violations of the bipartite steering inequality of the reduced pairwise qubit systems. We have derived a trade-off relation which is satisfied by those pairwise bipartite maximal steering… ▽ More In the present work, we address the question of how bipartite steering violation takes place among multi-partite systems (where each sub-system have Hilbert space dimension restricted to two) based on the maximal violations of the bipartite steering inequality of the reduced pairwise qubit systems. We have derived a trade-off relation which is satisfied by those pairwise bipartite maximal steering violations, which physically can be understood as providing restrictions on the distribution of steering among subsystems. For a three-qubit system, it is impossible that all pairs of qubits violate the steering inequality, and once a pair of qubits violates the steering inequality maximally, the other two pairs of qubits must both obey the steering inequality. We also present a complementarity relation between genuine entanglement present in a tripartite state and maximum bipartite steering violation by its reduced states. △ Less

Submitted 3 April, 2019; v1 submitted 19 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: Close to published version

Journal ref: Eur. Phys. J. D (2019) 73: 66

Quantum nonlocality does not demand all-out randomness in measurement choice

Authors: Manik Banik, Samir Kunkri, Avijit Misra, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Arup Roy, Amit Mukherjee, Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar

Abstract: Nonlocality is the most characteristic feature of quantum mechanics. John Bell, in his seminal 1964 work, proved that local-realism imposes a bound on the correlations among the measurement statistics of distant observers. Surpassing this bound rules out local-realistic description of microscopic phenomena, establishing the presence of nonlocal correlation. To manifest nonlocality, it requires, in… ▽ More Nonlocality is the most characteristic feature of quantum mechanics. John Bell, in his seminal 1964 work, proved that local-realism imposes a bound on the correlations among the measurement statistics of distant observers. Surpassing this bound rules out local-realistic description of microscopic phenomena, establishing the presence of nonlocal correlation. To manifest nonlocality, it requires, in the simplest scenario, two measurements performed randomly by each of two distant observers. In this work, we propose a novel framework where three measurements, two on Alice's side and one on Bob's side, suffice to reveal quantum nonlocality and hence does not require all-out randomness in measurement choice. Our method relies on a very naive operational task in quantum information theory, namely, the minimal error state discrimination. As a practical implication this method constitutes an economical entanglement detection scheme, which uses a less number of entangled states compared to all such existing schemes. Moreover, the method applies to class of generalized probability theories containing quantum theory as a special example. △ Less

Submitted 17 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 6+2 pages; Two figures; Comments welcome

Characterization of the quantumness of unsteerable tripartite correlations

Authors: Debarshi Das, C. Jebaratnam, Bihalan Bhattacharya, Amit Mukherjee, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Arup Roy

Abstract: Quantumness for a bipartite unsteerable quantum correlation is operationally characterized by the notion of super-unsteerability. Super-unsteerability refers to the requirement of a larger dimension of the random variable that the steering party has to preshare with the party to be steered in the classical simulation protocol to generate an unsteerable correlation than the local Hilbert space dime… ▽ More Quantumness for a bipartite unsteerable quantum correlation is operationally characterized by the notion of super-unsteerability. Super-unsteerability refers to the requirement of a larger dimension of the random variable that the steering party has to preshare with the party to be steered in the classical simulation protocol to generate an unsteerable correlation than the local Hilbert space dimension of the quantum states (reproducing the given unsteerable correlation) at the steering party's side. In the present study, this concept of super-unsteerability is generalized by defining the notion of super-bi-unsteerability for tripartite correlations, which is unsteerable across a bipartite cut. Genuine super-bi-unsteerability is defined as the occurrence of super-bi-unsteerability across all possible bipartite cuts. Specific example of genuine super-bi-unsteerability for tripartite correlations has been presented. This study provides a tool to characterize the genuine quantumness of tripartite quantum correlations which are unsteerable across every bipartite cut. △ Less

Submitted 24 September, 2018; v1 submitted 23 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: Close to published version

Journal ref: Annals of Physics, 398, 55-79 (2018)

Tripartite entanglement detection through tripartite quantum steering in one-sided and two-sided device-independent scenarios

Authors: C. Jebaratnam, Debarshi Das, Arup Roy, Amit Mukherjee, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Bihalan Bhattacharya, Alberto Riccardi, Debasis Sarkar

Abstract: In the present work, we study tripartite quantum steering of quantum correlations arising from two local dichotomic measurements on each side in the two types of partially device-independent scenarios: $1$-sided device-independent scenario where one of the parties performs untrusted measurements while the other two parties perform trusted measurements and $2$-sided device-independent scenario wher… ▽ More In the present work, we study tripartite quantum steering of quantum correlations arising from two local dichotomic measurements on each side in the two types of partially device-independent scenarios: $1$-sided device-independent scenario where one of the parties performs untrusted measurements while the other two parties perform trusted measurements and $2$-sided device-independent scenario where one of the parties performs trusted measurements while the other two parties perform untrusted measurements. We demonstrate that tripartite steering in the $2$-sided device-independent scenario is weaker than tripartite steering in the $1$-sided device-independent scenario by using two families of quantum correlations. That is these two families of quantum correlations in the $2$-sided device-independent framework detect tripartite entanglement through tripartite steering for a larger region than that in the $1$-sided device-independent framework. It is shown that tripartite steering in the $2$-sided device-independent scenario implies the presence of genuine tripartite entanglement of $2\times 2 \times 2$ quantum system, even if the correlation does not exhibit genuine nonlocality or genuine steering. △ Less

Submitted 18 July, 2018; v1 submitted 26 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 14 pages, 4 figures, accepted for publication in Physical Review A

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 98, 022101 (2018)

Two-Qubit Pure Entanglement as Optimal Social Welfare Resource in Bayesian Game

Authors: Manik Banik, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Nirman Ganguly, Tamal Guha, Amit Mukherjee, Ashutosh Rai, Arup Roy

Abstract: Entanglement is of paramount importance in quantum information theory. Its supremacy over classical correlations has been demonstrated in numerous information theoretic protocols. Here we study possible adequacy of quantum entanglement in Bayesian game theory, particularly in social welfare solution (SWS), a strategy which the players follow to maximize the sum of their payoffs. Given a multi-part… ▽ More Entanglement is of paramount importance in quantum information theory. Its supremacy over classical correlations has been demonstrated in numerous information theoretic protocols. Here we study possible adequacy of quantum entanglement in Bayesian game theory, particularly in social welfare solution (SWS), a strategy which the players follow to maximize the sum of their payoffs. Given a multi-partite quantum state as an advice, players can come up with several correlated strategies by performing local measurements on their parts of the quantum state. A quantum strategy is called quantum-SWS if it is advantageous over a classical equilibrium (CE) strategy in the sense that none of the players has to sacrifice their CE-payoff rather some have incentive and at the same time it maximizes the sum of all players' payoffs over all possible quantum advantageous strategies. Quantum state yielding such a quantum-SWS is called a quantum social welfare advice (SWA). We show that any two-qubit pure entangled state, even if it is arbitrarily close to a product state, can serve as quantum-SWA in some Bayesian game. Our result, thus, gives cognizance to the fact that every two-qubit pure entanglement is the best resource for some operational task. △ Less

Submitted 31 August, 2019; v1 submitted 8 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Comments: Accepted in Quantum (accepted version)

Journal ref: Quantum 3, 185 (2019)

Generation of Nonlocality

Authors: Kaushiki Mukherjee, Biswajit Paul, Debasis Sarkar, Amit Mukherjee, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Arup Roy, Nirman Ganguly

Abstract: Environmental influences are typical in any practical situation which in turn can have fatal effects on quantum resources. Bell nonlocality is such an important resource. Some environmental interactions can lead to nonlocality being lost. In such situations, it is vital to find possible prescriptions to retrieve nonlocality. The present work lays down one such prescription. Precisely, we have stud… ▽ More Environmental influences are typical in any practical situation which in turn can have fatal effects on quantum resources. Bell nonlocality is such an important resource. Some environmental interactions can lead to nonlocality being lost. In such situations, it is vital to find possible prescriptions to retrieve nonlocality. The present work lays down one such prescription. Precisely, we have studied some well-known classes of states under the ambit of the Bell-CHSH inequality in two qubits, where we start from a Bell-CHSH local state and can transform it into a nonlocal state through our protocol. The efficacy of the protocol is further established from the fact that it can retrieve nonlocality from states admitting a LHV(local hidden variable) model. The strength of the prescription is validated by the fact that it can generate nonlocality from states when even unitary action on the composite system fails. △ Less

Submitted 24 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 8 pages, 9 figures, revtex, comments welcome

Local marginals ameliorate device independent witnessing of genuine entanglement

Authors: Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Biswajit Paul, Arup Roy, Amit Mukherjee, C. Jebaratnam, Manik Banik

Abstract: We consider the problem of determining the presence of genuine multipartite entanglement through the violation of Mermin's Bell-type inequality (MI). Though the violation of MI cannot certify the presence of genuine nonlocality, but can certify genuine tripartite entanglement whenever the violation is strictly greater than $2\sqrt{2}$. Here we show that MI suffices as genuine entanglement witness… ▽ More We consider the problem of determining the presence of genuine multipartite entanglement through the violation of Mermin's Bell-type inequality (MI). Though the violation of MI cannot certify the presence of genuine nonlocality, but can certify genuine tripartite entanglement whenever the violation is strictly greater than $2\sqrt{2}$. Here we show that MI suffices as genuine entanglement witness even when its value is $2\sqrt{2}$ if at least two of the local marginal distributions are not completely random provided the local Hilbert space dimension of at least one of the sub-systems is two. Thus local marginals suffice as semi-device independent genuine entanglement witness. This is intriguing in a sense, as the local properties of a composite system can help to identify its global property. Furthermore, analyzing another quantity constructed from Mermin polynomials we show that genuine entanglement certification task for the correlations with MI violation equal to $2\sqrt{2}$ can actually be made fully device independent. △ Less

Submitted 28 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: Comments welcome, no figure

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 95, 042130 (2017)

Revealing Genuine Steering under Sequential Measurement Scenario

Authors: Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Biswajit Paul, Kaushiki Mukherjee, Debasis Sarkar

Abstract: Genuine steering is still not well understood enough in contrast to genuine entanglement and nonlocality. Here we provide a protocol which can reveal genuine steering under some restricted operations compared to the existing witnesses of genuine multipartite steering. Our method has an impression of some sort of hidden protocol in the same spirit of hidden nonlocality, which is well understood in… ▽ More Genuine steering is still not well understood enough in contrast to genuine entanglement and nonlocality. Here we provide a protocol which can reveal genuine steering under some restricted operations compared to the existing witnesses of genuine multipartite steering. Our method has an impression of some sort of hidden protocol in the same spirit of hidden nonlocality, which is well understood in bipartite scenario. We also introduce a genuine steering measure which indicates the enhancement of genuine steering in the final state of our protocol compared to the initial states. △ Less

Submitted 16 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Detection of Genuine Multipartite Entanglement in Quantum Network Scenario

Authors: Biswajit Paul, Kaushiki Mukherjee, Sumana Karmakar, Debasis Sarkar, Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy, Some Sankar Bhattacharya

Abstract: Experimental demonstration of entanglement needs to have a precise control of experimentalist over the system on which the measurements are performed as prescribed by an appropriate entanglement witness. To avoid such trust problem, recently device-independent entanglement witnesses (\emph{DIEW}s) for genuine tripartite entanglement have been proposed where witnesses are capable of testing genuine… ▽ More Experimental demonstration of entanglement needs to have a precise control of experimentalist over the system on which the measurements are performed as prescribed by an appropriate entanglement witness. To avoid such trust problem, recently device-independent entanglement witnesses (\emph{DIEW}s) for genuine tripartite entanglement have been proposed where witnesses are capable of testing genuine entanglement without precise description of Hilbert space dimension and measured operators i.e apparatus are treated as black boxes. Here we design a protocol for enhancing the possibility of identifying genuine tripartite entanglement in a device independent manner. We consider three mixed tripartite quantum states none of whose genuine entanglement can be detected by applying standard \emph{DIEW}s, but their genuine tripartite entanglement can be detected by applying the same when distributed in some suitable entanglement swapping network. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: 8 pages, 3 figures, revtex, comments welcome

Absolute Non-Violation of a Three-Setting Steering Inequality by Two-Qubit States

Authors: Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy, Biswajit Paul, Kaushiki Mukherjee, Indranil Chakrabarty, C. Jebaratnam, Nirman Ganguly

Abstract: Steerability is a characteristic nonlocal trait of quantum states lying in between entanglement and Bell nonlocality. A given quantum state is considered to be steerable if it violates a suitably chosen steering inequality. A quantum state which otherwise satisfies a certain inequality can violate the inequality under a global change of basis i.e, if the state is transformed by a nonlocal unitary… ▽ More Steerability is a characteristic nonlocal trait of quantum states lying in between entanglement and Bell nonlocality. A given quantum state is considered to be steerable if it violates a suitably chosen steering inequality. A quantum state which otherwise satisfies a certain inequality can violate the inequality under a global change of basis i.e, if the state is transformed by a nonlocal unitary operation. Intriguingly there are states which preserve their non-violation(pertaining to the said inequality) under any global unitary operation. The present work explores the effect of global unitary operations on the steering ability of a quantum state which live in two qubits. We characterize such states in terms of a necessary and sufficient condition on their spectrum. Such states are also characterized in terms of some analytic characteristics of the set to which they belong. Looking back at steerability the present work also provides a relation between steerability and quantum teleportation together with the derivation of a result related to the optimal violation of steering inequality . An analytic estimation of the size of such non-violating states in terms of purity is also obtained. Interestingly the estimation in terms of purity also gives a necessary and sufficient condition in terms of bloch parameters of the state. Illustrations from some signature class of quantum states further underscore our observations. △ Less

Submitted 6 June, 2017; v1 submitted 22 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: Comments are welcome, Two figures

Bell-CHSH Violation Under Global Unitary Operations: Necessary and Sufficient conditions

Authors: Nirman Ganguly, Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Biswajit Paul, Kaushiki Mukherjee

Abstract: The relation between Bell-CHSH violation and factorization of Hilbert space is considered here. That is, a state which is local in the sense of the Bell-CHSH inequality under a certain factorization of the underlying Hilbert space can be Bell-CHSH non-local under a different factorization. While this question has been addressed with respect to separability , the relation of the factorization with… ▽ More The relation between Bell-CHSH violation and factorization of Hilbert space is considered here. That is, a state which is local in the sense of the Bell-CHSH inequality under a certain factorization of the underlying Hilbert space can be Bell-CHSH non-local under a different factorization. While this question has been addressed with respect to separability , the relation of the factorization with Bell-CHSH violation has remained hitherto unexplored. We find here, that there is a set containing density matrices which do not exhibit Bell-CHSH violation under any factorization of the Hilbert space brought about by global unitary operations. Using the Cartan decomposition of $ SU(4) $,we characterize the set in terms of a necessary and sufficient criterion based on the spectrum of density matrices. Sufficient conditions are obtained to characterize such density matrices based on their bloch representations. For some classes of density matrices, necessary and sufficient conditions are derived in terms of bloch parameters. Furthermore, an estimation of the volume of such density matrices is achieved in terms of purity. The criterion is applied to some well-known class of states in two qubits.Since, both local filtering and global unitary operations influence Bell-CHSH violation of a state, a comparative study is made between the two operations. The inequivalence of the two operations(in terms of increasing Bell-CHSH violation) is exemplified through their action on some classes of states. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2017; v1 submitted 17 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: Updated version, new results added

Journal ref: International Journal of Quantum Information, Vol 16, No 4, 1850040 (2018)

Conditional steering under von-Neumann scenario

Authors: Kaushiki Mukherjee, Biswajit Paul, Sumana Karmakar, Debasis Sarkar, Amit Mukherjee, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Arup Roy

Abstract: In [\href{http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/037596019290711T}{Phys. Lett. A {\bf 166}, 293 (1992)}] Popescu characterized nonlocality of pure $n$-partite entangled systems by studying bipartite violation of local realism when $n-2$ number of parties perform projective measurements on their particles. A pertinent question in this scenario is whether similar characterization is possib… ▽ More In [\href{http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/037596019290711T}{Phys. Lett. A {\bf 166}, 293 (1992)}] Popescu characterized nonlocality of pure $n$-partite entangled systems by studying bipartite violation of local realism when $n-2$ number of parties perform projective measurements on their particles. A pertinent question in this scenario is whether similar characterization is possible for $n$-partite mixed entangled states also. In the present work we have followed an analogous approach so as to explore whether given a tripartite mixed entangled state the conditional bipartite states obtained by performing projective measurement on the third party, demonstrate a weaker form of nonlocality, quantum steering. We also compare this new phenomenon of conditional steering with existing notions of tripartite correlations. Interestingly the tripartite state need not be genuinely entangled to demonstrate conditional steering. △ Less

Submitted 30 March, 2017; v1 submitted 18 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 12 pages, 7 figures, revtex4, typos and errors corrected, comments welcome

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 96, 022122 (2017)

Persistency of Genuine Correlations Under Particle Loss

Authors: Biswajit Paul, Kaushiki Mukherjee, Ajoy Sen, Debasis Sarkar, Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy, Some Sankar Bhattacharya

Abstract: In a recent work [\href{http://journals.aps.org/pra/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevA.86.042113}{Phys. Rev. A 86, 042113 (2012)}] the question of persistency of entanglement and nonlocality of multi-party systems under particle loss has been addressed. This question is of immense importance considering the practical realization of the information theoretic tasks which make use of the power of quantum corr… ▽ More In a recent work [\href{http://journals.aps.org/pra/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevA.86.042113}{Phys. Rev. A 86, 042113 (2012)}] the question of persistency of entanglement and nonlocality of multi-party systems under particle loss has been addressed. This question is of immense importance considering the practical realization of the information theoretic tasks which make use of the power of quantum correlations. But in multipartite scenario more interesting cases arise since subsystems can also possess genuineness in correlation which is prevalently inequivalent to the bipartite scenario. In this work, we investigate the persistency of such genuine correlations under particle loss. Keeping in mind the practical importance, considerable attention has been devoted to find the multipartite states which exhibit maximal persistency of genuine correlations. △ Less

Submitted 9 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 11 pages, 3 figures, revtex4, draft, comments welcome. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1006.0036, arXiv:1207.3986 by other authors

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 102, 022401 (2020)

Characterization of Nonlocal Resources Under Global Unitary Action

Authors: Arup Roy, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Amit Mukherjee, Nirman Ganguly

Abstract: The task of device independent secure key distribution requires preparation and subsequently distribution of nonlocal resources. For secured practical implementation, one needs to take two initially uncorrelated quantum systems and perform a unitary on the composite system to generate the nonlocal resource, which is supposed to violate a Bell inequality (say, Bell-CHSH). States which do not violat… ▽ More The task of device independent secure key distribution requires preparation and subsequently distribution of nonlocal resources. For secured practical implementation, one needs to take two initially uncorrelated quantum systems and perform a unitary on the composite system to generate the nonlocal resource, which is supposed to violate a Bell inequality (say, Bell-CHSH). States which do not violate Bell-CHSH inequality, but violate it when transformed by a global unitary, can be deemed useful for the preparation of nonlocal resource. One may then start from a state which is Bell-CHSH local (take for example, a pure product state) and apply an appropriate global unitary on it which results in a Bell-CHSH non-local state. However, an intriguing fact is the existence of useless states from which no Bell-CHSH non-local resource can be generated with a global unitary. This is due to the purity preserving nature of unitary operators which bound the amount of correlation in the set of final states depending on the purity of the initial (possibly uncorrelated) states. The present work confirms the existence of such a set, pertaining to two qubit systems. The set exhibits counter intuitive features by containing within it some entangled states which remain Bell-CHSH local on the action of any unitary. From practical perspective, this work draws a line between useful and useless states for the task of preparing nonlocal resource using global unitary transformations. Furthermore through an analytic characterization of the set we lay down a generic prescription through which one can operationally identify the useful states. It has also been shown that our prescription remains valid for any linear Bell inequality. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2017; v1 submitted 14 August, 2016; originally announced August 2016.

Comments: Comments are welcome

Journal ref: Quantum Stud.: Math. Found. (2017)

The presence of quantum correlations result in non-vanishing ergotropic gap

Authors: Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Manik Banik

Abstract: The paradigm of extracting work from isolated quantum system through a cyclic Hamiltonian process is a topic of immense research interest. The optimal work extracted under such process is termed as ergotropy [Europhys. Lett., 67 (4), 565(2004)]. Here, in a multi-party scenario we consider only a class of such cyclic processes that can be implemented locally, giving rise to the concept of local erg… ▽ More The paradigm of extracting work from isolated quantum system through a cyclic Hamiltonian process is a topic of immense research interest. The optimal work extracted under such process is termed as ergotropy [Europhys. Lett., 67 (4), 565(2004)]. Here, in a multi-party scenario we consider only a class of such cyclic processes that can be implemented locally, giving rise to the concept of local ergotropy. Eventually, presence of quantum correlations result in a non-vanishing thermodynamic quantity called ergotropic gap, measured by the difference between the global and local ergotropy. However the converse does not hold in general, i.e. its nonzero value does not necessarily imply presence of quantum correlations. For arbitrary multi-party states we quantify this gap. We also evaluate the difference between maximum global and local extractable work for arbitrary states when the system is no longer isolated but put in contact with a baths of same local temperature. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Comments: Accepted in Phys. Rev. E

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 93, 052140 (2016)

Nonlocal correlations: Fair and Unfair Strategies in Bayesian Game

Authors: Arup Roy, Amit Mukherjee, Tamal Guha, Sibasish Ghosh, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Manik Banik

Abstract: Interesting connection has been established between two apparently unrelated concepts, namely, quantum nonlocality and Bayesian game theory. It has been shown that nonlocal correlations in the form of advice can outperform classical equilibrium strategies in common interest Bayesian games and also in conflicting interest games. However, classical equilibrium strategies can be of two types, fair an… ▽ More Interesting connection has been established between two apparently unrelated concepts, namely, quantum nonlocality and Bayesian game theory. It has been shown that nonlocal correlations in the form of advice can outperform classical equilibrium strategies in common interest Bayesian games and also in conflicting interest games. However, classical equilibrium strategies can be of two types, fair and unfair. Whereas in fair equilibrium payoffs of different players are same, in unfair case they differ. Advantage of nonlocal correlation has been demonstrated over fair strategies. In this work we show that quantum strategies can outperform even the unfair classical equilibrium strategies. For this purpose we consider a class of two players games which as a special case includes the conflicting game proposed in [Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 020401 (2015)]. These games can have both fair and unfair classical equilibria and also can have only unfair ones. We provide a simple analytic characterization of the nonlocal correlations that are advantageous over the classical equilibrium strategies in these games. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2016; v1 submitted 11 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: Modified manuscript: typos corrected

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 94, 032120 (2016)

Biased Non-Causal Game

Authors: Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Manik Banik

Abstract: The standard formulation of quantum theory assumes that events are ordered is a background global causal structure. Recently in Ref.[$\href{http://www.nature.com/ncomms/journal/v3/n10/full/ncomms2076.html}{Nat. Commun. {\bf3}, 1092 (2012)}$], the authors have developed a new formalism, namely, the \emph{process matrix} formalism, which is locally in agreement with quantum physics but assumes no gl… ▽ More The standard formulation of quantum theory assumes that events are ordered is a background global causal structure. Recently in Ref.[$\href{http://www.nature.com/ncomms/journal/v3/n10/full/ncomms2076.html}{Nat. Commun. {\bf3}, 1092 (2012)}$], the authors have developed a new formalism, namely, the \emph{process matrix} formalism, which is locally in agreement with quantum physics but assumes no global causal order. They have further shown that there exist \emph{non-causal} correlations originating from \emph{inseparable} process matrices that violate a \emph{causal inequality} (CI) derived under the assumption that events are ordered with respect to some global causal relation. This CI can be understood as a guessing game, where two separate parties, say Alice and Bob, generate random bits (say input bit) in their respective local laboratories. Bob generates another random bit (say decision bit) which determines their goal: whether Alice has to guess Bob's bit or vice-verse. Here we study this causal game but with biased bits and derive a biased causal inequality (BCI). We then study the possibility of violation of this BCI by inseparable process matrices. Interestingly, we show that there exist \emph{inseparable} qubit process matrices that can be used to violate the BCI for an arbitrary bias in the decision bit. In such scenario, we also derive the maximal violation of the BCI under local operations involving traceless binary observables. However, for biased input bits, we find that there is a threshold bias beyond which no valid qubit process matrix can be used to violate the causal inequality under \emph{measurement-repreparation} type operation. △ Less

Submitted 31 May, 2017; v1 submitted 9 September, 2015; originally announced September 2015.

Comments: Revised manuscript; comments are welcome

Reciprocal ontological models show indeterminism of the order of quantum theory

Authors: Somshubhro Bandyopadhyay, Manik Banik, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar, Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy

Abstract: The question whether indeterminism in quantum measurement outcomes is fundamental or is there a possibility of constructing a finer theory underlying quantum mechanics that allows no such indeterminism, has been debated for a long time. We show that within the class of ontological models due to Harrigan and Spekkens, those satisfying preparation-measurement reciprocity must allow indeterminism of… ▽ More The question whether indeterminism in quantum measurement outcomes is fundamental or is there a possibility of constructing a finer theory underlying quantum mechanics that allows no such indeterminism, has been debated for a long time. We show that within the class of ontological models due to Harrigan and Spekkens, those satisfying preparation-measurement reciprocity must allow indeterminism of the order of quantum theory. Our result implies that one can design quantum random number generator, for which it is impossible, even in principle, to construct a reciprocal deterministic model. △ Less

Submitted 10 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: Two column, 7 pages, 1 figure

Witnessing Genuine Mutipartite Non-locality

Authors: Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Arup Roy, Amit Mukherjee, Ramij Rahaman

Abstract: Genuine multipartite nonlocality is a salient feature of quantum systems, empowering the security of multi-party device independent cryptographic protocols. Given a correlation, characterizing and detecting genuineness have been subjected to recent studies. In this regard, we propose a Hardy-type argument which is able to detect genuine $n$-way nonlocality of arbitrary quantum systems. To understa… ▽ More Genuine multipartite nonlocality is a salient feature of quantum systems, empowering the security of multi-party device independent cryptographic protocols. Given a correlation, characterizing and detecting genuineness have been subjected to recent studies. In this regard, we propose a Hardy-type argument which is able to detect genuine $n$-way nonlocality of arbitrary quantum systems. To understand the strength of this argument we also study the optimal success probability of the argument in a minimally constrained theory, namely the generalized no-signaling theory. △ Less

Submitted 27 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 5 Pages. Initial draft. Comments are welcome

Limited preparation contextuality in quantum theory and its relation to the Cirel'son bound

Authors: Manik Banik, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy, Andris Ambainis, Ashutosh Rai

Abstract: Kochen-Specker (KS) theorem lies at the heart of the foundations of quantum mechanics. It establishes impossibility of explaining predictions of quantum theory by any noncontextual ontological model. Spekkens generalized the notion of KS contextuality in [Phys. Rev. A 71, 052108 (2005)] for arbitrary experimental procedures (preparation, measurement, and transformation procedure). Interestingly, l… ▽ More Kochen-Specker (KS) theorem lies at the heart of the foundations of quantum mechanics. It establishes impossibility of explaining predictions of quantum theory by any noncontextual ontological model. Spekkens generalized the notion of KS contextuality in [Phys. Rev. A 71, 052108 (2005)] for arbitrary experimental procedures (preparation, measurement, and transformation procedure). Interestingly, later on it was shown that preparation contextuality powers parity-oblivious multiplexing [Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 010401 (2009)], a two party information theoretic game. Thus, using resources of a given operational theory, the maximum success probability achievable in such a game suffices as a \emph{bona-fide} measure of preparation contextuality for the underlying theory. In this work we show that preparation contextuality in quantum theory is more restricted compared to a general operational theory known as \emph{box world}. Moreover, we find that this limitation of quantum theory implies the quantitative bound on quantum nonlocality as depicted by the Cirel'son bound. △ Less

Submitted 11 September, 2015; v1 submitted 16 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: (5+4) pages; Accepted in Phys. Rev. A (Rapid Communication). arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:0805.1463 by other authors

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 92, 030103(R) (2015)

Optimal quantum violation of Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt like steering inequality

Authors: Arup Roy, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Amit Mukherjee, Manik Banik

Abstract: We study a recently proposed Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen steering inequality [arXiv- 1412.8178 (2014)]. Analogous to Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality for Bell nonlocality, in the simplest scenario, i.e., 2 parties, 2 measurements per party and 2 outcomes per measurement, this newly proposed inequality has been proved to be necessary and sufficient for steering. In this article, using an eq… ▽ More We study a recently proposed Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen steering inequality [arXiv- 1412.8178 (2014)]. Analogous to Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality for Bell nonlocality, in the simplest scenario, i.e., 2 parties, 2 measurements per party and 2 outcomes per measurement, this newly proposed inequality has been proved to be necessary and sufficient for steering. In this article, using an equivalence between measurement incompatibility (non joint measurability) and steering, we find the optimal violation amount of this inequality in quantum theory. Interestingly, the optimal violation amount matches with optimal quantum violation of CHSH inequality, i.e., Cirel'son quantity. We further study the optimal violation of this inequality for different bipartite quantum states. To our surprise we find that optimal violation amount is different for different $2$-qubit pure entangled states, which is not the case for all other existing steering inequalities. △ Less

Submitted 16 March, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: 5.5 pages, 2 figures, Comments are welcome

Journal ref: J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 48 415302 (2015)

All-versus-nothing violation of local realism from the Hardy paradox under no-signaling

Authors: Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Arup Roy, Amit Mukherjee, Ramij Rahaman

Abstract: Hardy's is one of the simplest arguments concerning non-locality. Recently Chen et. al. have proposed a more generalized Hardy-like argument and have shown that the probability of success increases with local system's dimension. Here we study the same in a minimally constrained theory, namely the generalized no-signaling theory(GNST). We find that not only the probability of success of this argume… ▽ More Hardy's is one of the simplest arguments concerning non-locality. Recently Chen et. al. have proposed a more generalized Hardy-like argument and have shown that the probability of success increases with local system's dimension. Here we study the same in a minimally constrained theory, namely the generalized no-signaling theory(GNST). We find that not only the probability of success of this argument increases with local system dimension in GNST, it also takes a very simple functional form. △ Less

Submitted 27 July, 2015; v1 submitted 25 November, 2014; originally announced November 2014.

Comments: 5 pages, 1 figure. Title changed,figure updated. Close to published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 92, 012111(2015)

Device independent Schmidt rank witness by using Hardy paradox

Authors: Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Subhadipa Das, Md. Rajjak Gazi, Manik Banik

Abstract: Schmidt rank of bipartite pure state serves as a testimony of entanglement. It is a monotone under local operation + classical communications (LOCC) and puts restrictions in LOCC convertibility of quantum states. Identifying the Schmidt rank of an unknown quantum state therefore seek importance from information theoretic perspective. In this work it is shown that a modified version of Hardy's argu… ▽ More Schmidt rank of bipartite pure state serves as a testimony of entanglement. It is a monotone under local operation + classical communications (LOCC) and puts restrictions in LOCC convertibility of quantum states. Identifying the Schmidt rank of an unknown quantum state therefore seek importance from information theoretic perspective. In this work it is shown that a modified version of Hardy's argument, which reveals the contradiction of quantum theory with local realism, turns out to be useful for inspecting the minimal Schmidt rank of the unknown state and hence also the minimal dimension of the system. Use of Hardy's test in such task provides a practical advantage: the Schmidt rank can be determined without knowing the detailed functioning of the experimental devices i.e., Hardy's test suffices to be a device independent Schmidt rank witness. △ Less

Submitted 8 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 5 pages (1 figure); comments are welcome

Local deterministic simulation of equatorial Von Neumann measurements on tripartite GHZ state

Authors: Arup Roy, Amit Mukherjee, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Manik Banik, Subhadipa Das

Abstract: Experimental free-will or measurement independence is one of the crucial assumptions in derivation of any nonlocal theorem. Any nonlocal correlation obtained in quantum world can have a local deterministic explanation if there is no experimental free-will in choosing the measurement settings. Recently, in [Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf105}, 250404 (2010)] it has been shown that to obtain a local determini… ▽ More Experimental free-will or measurement independence is one of the crucial assumptions in derivation of any nonlocal theorem. Any nonlocal correlation obtained in quantum world can have a local deterministic explanation if there is no experimental free-will in choosing the measurement settings. Recently, in [Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf105}, 250404 (2010)] it has been shown that to obtain a local deterministic description for singlet state correlation one does not need to give up measurement independence completely, but a partial measurement dependence suffices. In three party scenario considering GHZ correlation one can exhibit absolute contradiction between quantum theory and local realism. In this paper we show that such correlation also has local deterministic description if measurement independence is given up, even if not completely. We provide a local deterministic model for equatorial Von Neumann measurements on tripartite GHZ state by sacrificing measurement independence partially. △ Less

Submitted 18 September, 2014; v1 submitted 31 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: Accepted in Quantum Inf Process (close to accepted version)

Journal ref: Quantum Inf Process 14, 217-228 (2014)

Ontological models, preparation contextuality and nonlocality

Authors: Manik Banik, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Sujit K Choudhary, Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy

Abstract: The ontological model framework for an operational theory has generated much interest in recent years. The debate concerning reality of quantum states has been made more precise in this framework. With the introduction of generalized notion of contextuality in this framework, it has been shown that completely mixed state of a qubit is \emph{preparation contextual}. Interestingly, this new idea of… ▽ More The ontological model framework for an operational theory has generated much interest in recent years. The debate concerning reality of quantum states has been made more precise in this framework. With the introduction of generalized notion of contextuality in this framework, it has been shown that completely mixed state of a qubit is \emph{preparation contextual}. Interestingly, this new idea of preparation contextuality has been used to demonstrate nonlocality of some $ψ$-epistemic models without any use of Bell's inequality. In particular, nonlocality of a non maximally $ψ$-epistemic model has been demonstrated from preparation contextuality of a maximally mixed qubit and Schrödinger's steerability of the maximally entangled state of two qubits [Phys. Rev. Lett {\bf 110}, 120401 (2013)]. In this paper, we, show that any mixed state is preparation contextual. We, then, show that nonlocality of any bipartite pure entangled state, with Schmidt rank two, follows from preparation contextuality and steerability provided we impose certain condition on the epistemicity of the underlying ontological model. More interestingly, if the pure entangled state is of Schmidt rank greater than two, its nonlocality follows without any further condition on the epistemicity. Thus our result establishes a stronger connection between nonlocality and preparation contextuality by revealing nonlocality of any bipartite pure entangled states without any use of Bell-type inequality. △ Less

Submitted 18 September, 2014; v1 submitted 30 July, 2013; originally announced July 2013.

Comments: Accepted in Foundations of Physics (close to accepted version). arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:quant-ph/0406166 by other authors

Journal ref: Foundations of Physics 44, 1230-1244 (2014)