-
Comparing indirect methods for black hole masses in AGN: the good, the bad, and the ugly
Authors:
M. Gliozzi,
J. K. Williams,
A. Akylas,
I. E. Papadakis,
O. I. Shuvo,
A. Halavatkar,
A. Alt
Abstract:
The black hole mass MBH is crucial in constraining the growth of supermassive BHs within their host galaxies. Since direct measurements of MBH with dynamical methods are restricted to a limited number of nearly quiescent nearby galaxies and a small minority of active galactic nuclei (AGN), we must rely on indirect methods. In this work, we utilize an unbiased, volume-limited, hard X-ray selected s…
▽ More
The black hole mass MBH is crucial in constraining the growth of supermassive BHs within their host galaxies. Since direct measurements of MBH with dynamical methods are restricted to a limited number of nearly quiescent nearby galaxies and a small minority of active galactic nuclei (AGN), we must rely on indirect methods. In this work, we utilize an unbiased, volume-limited, hard X-ray selected sample of AGN to compare the reliability of some commonly used indirect methods, emphasising those that can be applied to obscured AGN. Based on a subsample of AGN with MBH determined via dynamical methods, our study suggests that X-ray based techniques, such as the scaling method and the one based on the variability measured through the excess variance, are in good agreement with the dynamical methods. On the other hand, the M-sigma correlation based on inactive galaxies tends to systematically overestimate MBH, regardless of the level of obscuration. We provide a correcting factor that produces an acceptable agreement with dynamical values and can be used to quickly correct the MBH computed with this method. We also derive an alternative M-sigma correlation based on this unbiased sample of AGN with a slope considerably shallower than the ones obtained using inactive galaxies, suggesting that the latter correlation may not be appropriate to compute the MBH in AGN. Finally, we find that no quick fix can be applied to correct the MBH obtained from the fundamental plane of black hole activity, casting doubts on the reliability of this method.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Laboratory study of the failed torus mechanism in arched, line-tied, magnetic flux ropes
Authors:
Andrew Alt,
Hantao Ji,
Jongsoo Yoo,
Sayak Bose,
Aaron Goodman,
Masaaki Yamada
Abstract:
Coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are some of the most energetic and violent events in our solar system. The prediction and understanding of CMEs is of particular importance due to the impact that they can have on Earth-based satellite systems, and in extreme cases, ground-based electronics. CMEs often occur when long-lived magnetic flux ropes (MFRs) anchored to the solar surface destabilize and erupt…
▽ More
Coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are some of the most energetic and violent events in our solar system. The prediction and understanding of CMEs is of particular importance due to the impact that they can have on Earth-based satellite systems, and in extreme cases, ground-based electronics. CMEs often occur when long-lived magnetic flux ropes (MFRs) anchored to the solar surface destabilize and erupt away from the Sun. One potential cause for these eruptions is an ideal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) instability such as the kink or torus instability. Previous experiments on the Magnetic Reconnection eXperiment (MRX) revealed a class of MFRs that were torus-unstable but kink-stable, which failed to erupt. These "failed-tori" went through a process similar to Taylor relaxation where the toroidal current was redistributed before the eruption ultimately failed. We have investigated this behavior through additional diagnostics that measure the current distribution at the foot points and the energy distribution before and after an event. These measurements indicate that ideal MHD effects are sufficient to explain the energy distribution changes during failed torus events. This excludes Taylor relaxation as a possible mechanism of current redistribution during an event. A new model that only requires non-ideal effects in a thin layer above the electrodes is presented to explain the observed phenomena. This work broadens our understanding of the stability of MFRs and the mechanism behind the failed torus through the improved prediction of the torus instability and through new diagnostics to measure the energy inventory and current profile at the foot points.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Laboratory study of the torus instability threshold in solar-relevant, line-tied magnetic flux ropes
Authors:
Andrew Alt,
Clayton E. Myers,
Hantao Ji,
Jonathan Jara-Almonte,
Jongsoo Yoo,
Sayak Bose,
Aaron Goodman,
Masaaki Yamada,
Bernhard Kliem,
Antonia Savcheva
Abstract:
Coronal mass ejections (CME) occur when long-lived magnetic flux ropes (MFR) anchored to the solar surface destabilize and erupt away from the Sun. This destabilization is often described in terms of an ideal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) instability called the torus instability. It occurs when the external magnetic field decreases sufficiently fast such that its decay index,…
▽ More
Coronal mass ejections (CME) occur when long-lived magnetic flux ropes (MFR) anchored to the solar surface destabilize and erupt away from the Sun. This destabilization is often described in terms of an ideal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) instability called the torus instability. It occurs when the external magnetic field decreases sufficiently fast such that its decay index, $n=-z\,\partial\,(\ln B)/\partial z$ is larger than a critical value, $n>n_{\rm cr}$, where $n_{\rm cr}=1.5$ for a full, large aspect ratio torus. However, when this is applied to solar MFRs, a range of conflicting values for $n_{\rm cr}$ is found in the literature. To investigate this discrepancy, we have conducted laboratory experiments on arched, line-tied flux ropes and have applied a theoretical model of the torus instability. Our model describes an MFR as a partial torus with footpoints anchored in a conducting surface and numerically calculates various magnetic forces on it. This calculation yields a better prediction of $n_{\rm cr}$ which takes into account the specific parameters of the MFR. We describe a systematic methodology to properly translate laboratory results to their solar counterparts, provided that the MFRs have sufficiently small edge safety factor, or equivalently, large enough twist. After this translation, our model predicts that $n_{\rm cr}$ in solar conditions often falls near $n_{\rm cr}^{\rm Sol}\sim0.9$ and within a larger range of $n_{\rm cr}^{\rm Sol}\sim(0.7,1.2)$ depending on the parameters. The methodology of translating laboratory MFRs to their solar counterparts enables quantitative investigations of the initiation of CMEs through laboratory experiments. These experiments allow for new physics insights that are required for better predictions of space weather events but are difficult to obtain otherwise.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Major Scientific Challenges and Opportunities in Understanding Magnetic Reconnection and Related Explosive Phenomena in Solar and Heliospheric Plasmas
Authors:
H. Ji,
J. Karpen,
A. Alt,
S. Antiochos,
S. Baalrud,
S. Bale,
P. M. Bellan,
M. Begelman,
A. Beresnyak,
A. Bhattacharjee,
E. G. Blackman,
D. Brennan,
M. Brown,
J. Buechner,
J. Burch,
P. Cassak,
B. Chen,
L. -J. Chen,
Y. Chen,
A. Chien,
L. Comisso,
D. Craig,
J. Dahlin,
W. Daughton,
E. DeLuca
, et al. (83 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Magnetic reconnection underlies many explosive phenomena in the heliosphere and in laboratory plasmas. The new research capabilities in theory/simulations, observations, and laboratory experiments provide the opportunity to solve the grand scientific challenges summarized in this whitepaper. Success will require enhanced and sustained investments from relevant funding agencies, increased interagen…
▽ More
Magnetic reconnection underlies many explosive phenomena in the heliosphere and in laboratory plasmas. The new research capabilities in theory/simulations, observations, and laboratory experiments provide the opportunity to solve the grand scientific challenges summarized in this whitepaper. Success will require enhanced and sustained investments from relevant funding agencies, increased interagency/international partnerships, and close collaborations of the solar, heliospheric, and laboratory plasma communities. These investments will deliver transformative progress in understanding magnetic reconnection and related explosive phenomena including space weather events.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Major Scientific Challenges and Opportunities in Understanding Magnetic Reconnection and Related Explosive Phenomena throughout the Universe
Authors:
H. Ji,
A. Alt,
S. Antiochos,
S. Baalrud,
S. Bale,
P. M. Bellan,
M. Begelman,
A. Beresnyak,
E. G. Blackman,
D. Brennan,
M. Brown,
J. Buechner,
J. Burch,
P. Cassak,
L. -J. Chen,
Y. Chen,
A. Chien,
D. Craig,
J. Dahlin,
W. Daughton,
E. DeLuca,
C. F. Dong,
S. Dorfman,
J. Drake,
F. Ebrahimi
, et al. (75 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This white paper summarizes major scientific challenges and opportunities in understanding magnetic reconnection and related explosive phenomena as a fundamental plasma process.
This white paper summarizes major scientific challenges and opportunities in understanding magnetic reconnection and related explosive phenomena as a fundamental plasma process.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Onset of magnetic reconnection in a collisionless, high-beta plasma
Authors:
Andrew Alt,
Matthew W. Kunz
Abstract:
In a magnetized, collisionless plasma, the magnetic moment of the constituent particles is an adiabatic invariant. An increase in the magnetic-field strength in such a plasma thus leads to an increase in the thermal pressure perpendicular to the field lines. Above a $β$-dependent threshold (where $β$ is the ratio of thermal to magnetic pressure), this pressure anisotropy drives the mirror instabil…
▽ More
In a magnetized, collisionless plasma, the magnetic moment of the constituent particles is an adiabatic invariant. An increase in the magnetic-field strength in such a plasma thus leads to an increase in the thermal pressure perpendicular to the field lines. Above a $β$-dependent threshold (where $β$ is the ratio of thermal to magnetic pressure), this pressure anisotropy drives the mirror instability, producing strong distortions in the field lines on ion-Larmor scales. The impact of this instability on magnetic reconnection is investigated using a simple analytical model for the formation of a current sheet (CS) and the associated production of pressure anisotropy. The difficulty in maintaining an isotropic, Maxwellian particle distribution during the formation and subsequent thinning of a CS in a collisionless plasma, coupled with the low threshold for the mirror instability in a high-$β$ plasma, imply that the geometry of reconnecting magnetic fields can differ radically from the standard Harris-sheet profile often used in simulations of collisionless reconnection. As a result, depending on the rate of CS formation and the initial CS thickness, tearing modes whose growth rates and wavenumbers are boosted by this difference may disrupt the mirror-infested CS before standard tearing modes can develop. A quantitative theory is developed to illustrate this process, which may find application in the tearing-mediated disruption of kinetic magnetorotational "channel" modes.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2019; v1 submitted 9 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
An Algorithm for Optimal Partitioning of Data on an Interval
Authors:
Brad Jackson,
Jeffrey D. Scargle,
David Barnes,
Sundararajan Arabhi,
Alina Alt,
Peter Gioumousis,
Elyus Gwin,
Paungkaew Sangtrakulcharoen,
Linda Tan,
Tun Tao Tsai
Abstract:
Many signal processing problems can be solved by maximizing the fitness of a segmented model over all possible partitions of the data interval. This letter describes a simple but powerful algorithm that searches the exponentially large space of partitions of $N$ data points in time $O(N^2)$. The algorithm is guaranteed to find the exact global optimum, automatically determines the model order (t…
▽ More
Many signal processing problems can be solved by maximizing the fitness of a segmented model over all possible partitions of the data interval. This letter describes a simple but powerful algorithm that searches the exponentially large space of partitions of $N$ data points in time $O(N^2)$. The algorithm is guaranteed to find the exact global optimum, automatically determines the model order (the number of segments), has a convenient real-time mode, can be extended to higher dimensional data spaces, and solves a surprising variety of problems in signal detection and characterization, density estimation, cluster analysis and classification.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2004; v1 submitted 17 September, 2003;
originally announced September 2003.